Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
262printed page
scan 276 of 434
Facsimile · scan 276 of 434
Scan of p. 262
English · AI translation, not yet checked

A glance into their desolate synagogues, where the Minyan for daily prayer generally has to be paid, shows how they cultivate and preserve the faith in their communities. Among the Jewish masses, they have been unable to maintain the knowledge of the Hebrew language and of Jewish history, customs, and traditions, so that the people are almost completely alienated from Jewish tradition. The Jewish rich, who give them their office and salary, show them ironically what they think of a Judaism embodied by the Protest Rabbis, by having themselves or their children baptized one after another. Now these valiant Protest Rabbis are courting the Jewish rich by raising their sanctimonious voices in the name of the Jewish religion against Zionism. Those more qualified than I have taken the Jewish religion under their protection against these unexpected defenders. From my standpoint as a Jewish freethinker, I can only say: this trait, the hostility toward the most genuine and profound movement the Jewish people has ever known, was hitherto missing from the character portrait of the Protest Rabbis. Now the picture is complete. We have only them to thank for satisfying our aesthetic demands for uniformity of character and our need for consistency.

But while we can disregard the opposition of the Protest Rabbis, while the indifference or hostility of the Jewish millionaires concerns us only insofar as it makes it more difficult for us to raise the funds to realize the Zionist idea, there is a rejection, a denial of Zionism, that strikes us to the heart. That is the rejection by the Jewish workers, the Jewish proletarians. Even if these rise up against us, even if they declare that they want to know nothing of Zionism,