Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
246printed page
scan 260 of 434
Facsimile · scan 260 of 434
Scan of p. 246
English · AI translation, not yet checked

246

Jews have the mission to live in diaspora among the peoples in order to give them teaching and example. Fine. How, for example, are the 260,000 Romanian Jews supposed to fulfill this mission? If they remain in the country, they will give the Romanians the example of starvation. I do not believe that this example will entice the Romanians to imitation. But if, to save their lives, they leave the country, what then of the teaching? Should they perhaps instruct the Romanians from afar? By letter, perhaps? According to the Langenscheidt method? Good. But then it would surely be better if they wrote their instructional letters to the Romanians from Palestine than from twenty other countries. No. This profound-sounding chatter about the mission of the Jewish people is a foolishness not worthy of holding the attention of a serious person for even a minute.

I come to the last of Zangwill's solutions: the status quo. There is nothing to be done. Everything should remain as it is. The Jews who wish to individually escape the Jewish fate should let themselves be baptized. The Jews who are well off should continue to live happily, continue to trade, continue to build. The Jews who are tormented should continue to bear their misery, as they have borne it for 1800 years, and console themselves with the hope that bad times might perhaps be followed by better ones. This solution seems most practical; the pure Egg of Columbus. It recommends itself through its simplicity and elegance. It has the inestimable advantage that it demands no effort from anyone, only superhuman submission and patience from the poor and miserable. It appeals powerfully to common sense, which is always an enemy of day-dreaming, of project-making, of extravagant idealism. Now, the trained philosopher knows that the famous common sense, as a rule