Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
239printed page
scan 253 of 434

239

A Jewish proverb, with which you are all familiar, says: You don’t go into the forest for a pretext. When one is firmly resolved to reject a thought, a proposal, an undertaking outright, one is never at a loss for reasons for the rejection. Whoever wants to drown his dog, calls him rabid and throws him cheerfully into the water. First, there is the wish to kill the poor animal. Then the excuse that he is rabid presents itself at the right time. By far, most Jewish opponents of Zionism do not feel with the Jewish masses and feel nothing for the Jewish people. Since no emotional impulse causes them to perceive the current situation of the Jews as unbearable, since no emotional impulse awakens in them the desire for change, for improvement of the situation, Zionism must, with psychological necessity, appear to them as something unfounded, unnecessary, and absurd, and all that is left for them to do is to subsequently seek to justify this first, immediate impression, given by feeling, with reason. By the same psychological paths by which the Jewish opponents of Zionism arrive at their objections to this great popular movement, its supporters come to their rock-solid conviction of the indispensability and feasibility of Zionism. They feel that Israel is suffering the pangs of death and that it wants to and must be redeemed, and therefore the plan of redemption of Zionism is as clear as day to them. The wish is indeed the father of the thought, and wish is just another expression for feeling; it is feeling in action.

A fundamentally negative stance against Zionism has no justification whatsoever. It only proves that in the hearts of its opponents, every spark of Jewish feeling has been extinguished. It is, of course, a different matter with those who