arise not only from unknown biological reasons, which were active in primeval times, but also from historical ones, which can sometimes be caught in the act. When an immense majority of a people declares to a precisely defined minority of the people: “You do not belong to us, you are strangers among us,” then this minority has no choice but to adjust to this termination of community; and if the outcast minority feels this ostracism in its soul as unbearably painful, then its instinct for self-preservation justifies the endeavor to create for itself more painless conditions of existence. Therefore: even if it were true that the Jews today are not a people, antisemitism would be a sufficient reason for them to become a people.
The revival of Jewish nationhood “contradicts the spirit of the Jewish religion, falsifies it, is quackery.” “Out of the intention to help Judaism, Judaism can be ruined.” Dr. Güdemann therefore rejects Zionism so that Judaism does not come to harm. As the means to preserve it, he recommends assimilation. He covers this recommendation with some names of authority; besides Philo and Maimonides, who were very good Jews and whose nature, life, and writings raise the sharpest objection against the use of their names to support the thesis of Dr. Güdemann, he also names Mendelssohn. With this citation, he is lucky! Mendelssohn was such a successful assimilator that all his descendants today are good Christians and pillars of the Evangelical State Church in Prussia. That is at least consistent. Does Dr. Güdemann want this assimilation? Then he has chosen the appropriate standpoint. He does not stand alone in this viewpoint. The Pole Frank has
