219
to press a cash alms into their hands, they send them to Palestine, settle them there as farmers or vintners, and continue to support them until they can sustain themselves through their own work, which in most cases is still not achieved even after many years. We do not fail to recognize the merits of the practical Zionists. They have, albeit with disproportionate sacrifices, nevertheless improved the situation of a few thousand pitiable Jews. They have sown a seed on the soil of Palestine that will perhaps sprout. They were guided by a Jewish ideal that was not always clearly conscious. They wanted at least some Jews to once again plow the soil of the ancient homeland of the Jewish people, that at least a few examples would provide living proof of the historical connection between the Jewish people and the Holy Land. That is why they found the charity colonies specifically in Palestine and not elsewhere, although small-scale colonization there is much more expensive and has to contend with much more unfavorable conditions than, for example, in America and Australia.
We, the political Zionists, conceive of our task differently. We do not want small-scale colonization, but rather large-scale immigration. We do not want wretched settlements of alms recipients, but rather the permanent liberation of all persecuted Jews through self-help. This goal cannot be achieved with the methods of the practical Zionists. It does not help us to obtain a perpetually doubtful legal title to a few hectares of land through the lavish distribution of baksheesh, and to smuggle in a few settlers in defiance of the prohibition of the Turkish authorities, only to then abandon them to the arbitrary will of a Turkish pasha. We want the Turks to give us the land that is currently desolate and masterless, or the land that belongs to the Crown, but is at present
