Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
204printed page
scan 218 of 434
Facsimile · scan 218 of 434
Scan of p. 204
English · AI translation, not yet checked

...and rank must be shown external respect, and every kick that leaves its dirty mark on the caftan implies an intention that morally also affects the official robe of the Jewish judge and university professor and the silk robe of the Jewish baroness. Therefore, if not out of fraternity, we must, in our own well-understood self-interest, do what is possible to lift the degraded or already degraded Jews of the East to a higher economic, moral, and spiritual level.

This is my answer to the objection that Judaism does not need Zionism for its continued existence. The more highly educated Jews of the West will no longer wish to be despised and will fall away; those who are insensitive to contempt will sink into a repulsive materialism and will truly deserve the contempt; but the Jews of the East will perish, body and soul. In a misty, distant future, antisemitism will, of course, also cease. But if Judaism is to remain exposed to hatred and contempt until then, the golden age of pure humanity and universal fraternity will find no more Jews who could enjoy its sunshine.

Now to the second objection against Zionism. It could harm the non-Zionist Jews. This objection stems from such a naively shameless selfishness that one has difficulty discussing it with equanimity. It amounts to this: that a minority of about one-fifth of comfortable and sated Jews says to the four-fifths majority of desperate Jews, resolved to the most extreme acts of self-help: “How dare you disturb our digestion with your wild invocation of Zion? Why don’t you stifle your suffering? Why don’t you starve