194
This then is our answer to those critics and opponents of Zionism who wish for the disappearance of the Jewish people. We say to them: "First, your solution is incomparably more chimerical than the Zionist one, for nine-tenths of the Jews want to remain Jews, and even if they wanted to stop being Jews, antisemitism would recognize them behind any mass disguise and continue to persecute them. Secondly, however, it is really too kind of us to engage in a discussion with you and in a refutation of your peculiar views. Your program excludes you from Judaism. Zionism, however, is an internal matter for the Jewish people. So please, mind your own business and kindly leave it to us to take care of our own."
Now we come to those opponents of Zionism who genuinely or allegedly wish for the preservation of Judaism. Their objections can be summarized in these three sentences of diminishing severity: Zionism is an impracticable folly. Zionism is a danger to Judaism. Zionism is unnecessary, and Judaism will continue to exist without it, as it has for eighteen centuries. One also hears two other objections, which I would like to call the mystical ones. It is said to be interfering with the plans of Providence when the Jews rouse themselves to self-redemption, instead of waiting devotedly for the appearance of the promised Messiah. To this criticism I cannot answer, because it speaks a language that I do not understand and do not speak. Perhaps there are scribes who can prove to the unctuously pious, from all sorts of chapters and verses, that they misunderstand the promises of the prophets. And if it
