Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
191printed page
scan 205 of 434
Facsimile · scan 205 of 434
Scan of p. 191
English · AI translation, not yet checked

191 you are as little called upon to give advice as, say, to offer your advice to the Storting parties in Christiania.”

That is our answer to those Jews whose program is briefly: “Disappear!” And we also want to give them an example, the imitation of which we ask. We do not fight them, as long as they leave us in peace.

We do not seek to convince them of the falseness and reprehensibility of their direction. We do not want to place any obstacle in the way of their apostasy from Judaism. And yet we have a far better right to concern ourselves with them than they have to concern themselves with us.

For we feel ourselves to be Jews, which they do not, and therefore nothing Jewish is indifferent to us, whereas with them this is probably the case.

Not that we have no opinion on their program. Oh yes, we do have an opinion on it. We are convinced that their method does not solve the Jewish question.

The individual who, through baptism or in any other form, shakes off Judaism, perhaps achieves his purpose of disappearing without a trace into the mass of his Christian countrymen.

I say: perhaps, because for this to succeed, a whole number of prerequisites are necessary, which are not too often found together.

The fugitive from Judaism must not live in a small place, where the neighborhood has known him and his family for generations; for in these surroundings he, and his descendants, will for at least several generations always remain the baptized Jews and be clearly distinguished from the genuine, full-blooded Aryans.

He must therefore either be a bird of passage from his parents' or grandparents' time, or become a bird of passage himself; he must become a fugitive not only from his tribe, but also from his familiar human surroundings, otherwise the wanted poster of the Jew will follow him-