Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
146printed page
scan 160 of 434
Facsimile · scan 160 of 434
Scan of p. 146
English · AI translation, not yet checked

146

oppressed, but we have never stepped before all the powers and told them openly and clearly, in a positive formulation, what we want. Neither we ourselves, nor others, can reproach us for this. The Jewish people was chaotic; it formed no organism; it was human dust; it did not know itself what it wanted; it had no appointed representation that could speak in its name; and since it did not know itself what it wanted, the governments, of course, could not know this either. To have changed that seems like a small thing, but in reality it is very much. We have demanded! We have demanded that Palestine be opened to us, with the self-evident preservation of the sovereign rights of the Sultan, with the equally self-evident extraterritorialization of the Holy Sites, to which all of Christendom is attached with its deepest feelings of veneration and love, but at the same time with the guarantee of the indispensable minimum of self-governing rights, without which we could not live out our national life even in Palestine.

From more than one official quarter, although wrapped in polite form, we have been answered with something like this: "You are dissatisfied and want to emigrate. We compliment you on this decision, which testifies to your self-respect and your energy. But this requires no government action. We place not the slightest obstacle in the way of your emigration and even give you our best wishes for the journey." At that point, perhaps for the first time in our lives, we were not allowed to have a sense of humor, but had to reply with unshakable, respectful seriousness: Pardon, it is not enough to open the doors if the doorway is walled up on the outside. You permit us to depart, but no one permits us to enter. Since we do not assume that you with