A TEMPLE CONTROVERSY
("Die Welt", No. 2, 1897.)
The Chief Rabbi of Vienna, Dr. M. Güdemann, has felt compelled to oppose, in a pamphlet titled "National Judaism," the movement that has gripped deep strata of the population, which more developed minds among the Jews are joining in daily growing numbers, and whose goal is the acquisition of a life-securing soil for the national organism, which until now has been driven about like a Rose of Jericho, with an eternal alternation of brief moments of blossoming and long periods of wilting and shrinking. I have read this pamphlet with a kind of shame. My Jewish sense of belonging positively suffers from the intellectual inferiority of this work, of which its author, with even the slightest degree of foresight, could have told himself that it would provoke serious scrutiny and merciless rejection, and which he therefore should have at least somewhat armed for the inevitable struggle for its existence.
The contradictions in the pamphlet are so frequent and astonishing, they stand in such close proximity to one another, that I ask myself: did Dr. Güdemann, as he wrote it, lose the thread of his argument at every moment? Or was he under the influence of suddenly vacillating, conflict-
1
