Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
90printed page
scan 104 of 434
Facsimile · scan 104 of 434
Scan of p. 90
English · AI translation, not yet checked

90

to concede and grimly to deny that the Jews are a people. They are the only ones who still deny this. In a negative form, by way of exclusion, all peoples acknowledge it, by telling us Jews: "You do not belong to our people, even though you possess civil rights with us."

How poor must be the mathematics and logic of the deniers if they do not grasp that all these negations combined are the strongest affirmation of Jewish peoplehood! At first, we were very bitter against these adversaries. We have become calmer, perhaps also more just. We understand them, and to understand all is to forgive all. It was hard enough for them to attain a fatherland and civil rights, and now they have a certain nervous fear of losing them again.

What they have, they know; what Zionism will offer them, they do not yet see, because they lack the ability to look into the future and to imagine that which is only planned, not yet executed. Today they see in Zionism only a disturbance of their possessions and reject it with indignation. But it is precisely their intellectual and character peculiarities that guarantee to me that they will give up their resistance once we can show a beginning of tangible results.

In the struggle, we cannot count on these Jews. Some of them will even stab us in the back. In victory, however, many of them will probably come to us. Well, they shall be welcome to us even then. After all, they are not responsible for their shortsighted soul and for their faintheartedness.

I will perhaps astonish you when I tell you that I myself regard the renegades, the Jewish anti-Semites, the sycophants of the aristocratic salons more leniently...