Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
88printed page
scan 102 of 434
Facsimile · scan 102 of 434
Scan of p. 88
English · AI translation, not yet checked

88

Why? I know the reason and I will state it, although this costs me a great effort; for the reason is deeply shameful. It seems unbelievable, but is nevertheless true: there are still millions of Jews who know nothing of the entire Zionist movement. They long for Zionism and have not learned that their longing has taken the form of a positive political program. They pray every day for the return to Jerusalem and do not suspect that we are working with the commitment of our entire being to prepare for this return. And the tragic thing is that they are not to blame for their ignorance. Our word does not reach them. They read no newspapers. They go to no assemblies. The most terrible struggle for existence takes up every one of their moments so completely that they have no time or mind left for anything that does not relate to the immediate acquisition of a bite of bread. But these millions go to the synagogue; most of them daily, all on the Sabbath and on the holidays. They look up to their Rabbis as to their appointed teachers. The Rabbis have their ear — they had the duty to proclaim to them the good news of the new Zionism. Why have they not fulfilled this duty?

To be clear: I am not thinking here of the so-called protest-rabbis of the West. We are done with them and hope that the Jewish people will soon be done with them too.

I have in mind the faithful Rabbis of the East, whose good Jewish sentiment no one will reasonably doubt.

We ask these Rabbis: "Why do you stand aside? Why are you silent? Why do you lead your community, which