Ignaz Zollschan · The Racial Problem · 1912
427printed page
scan 479 of 568
Facsimile · scan 479 of 568
Scan of p. 427
English · AI translation, not yet checked

427 The idealism has subsided almost everywhere, except in a few centers of agitation. The number of those who pay the shekel, which signifies membership in the party, has fallen enormously. All the excellent results of the so-called practical Palestine work, in view of the magnitude of the overall problem and in view of the without exception blunt rejection of the Zionist idea by all factors that would come into consideration for its realization, have only the value of a—admittedly successful—experiment in a test tube. The internal weakness is that since Herzl's death the party seems to be, while not aimless, then planless, that all corporations are held together only with difficulty and almost only mechanically, and that idealism, because it was without opera operanda, had to slacken over time. Herzl's effort in the early years was directed above all at achieving great expressions of will within Jewry in favor of Zionism. The first two Congresses brought very important reports on the situation of the Jews in all countries and also the desired expressions of will, —though on the whole only from the proletarian masses. Once the expression of will had occurred, the natural and, through agitation, further fanned immense enthusiasm could no longer have any real goals. The diplomatic attempts to obtain the desired concessions from Turkey could necessarily only be the work of a very few people. The following Congresses could essentially decide nothing different anymore. Pure formalities about party organization, hard-to-implement resolutions for the founding of many and huge enterprises with the available small funds, election of commissions, etc., could not possibly be adequate for the existing gigantic will. Beautiful and in themselves also great creations like the Bank and the National Fund are still, measured against the magnitude of the task, relatively insignificant. But the only incisive, important, and truly great discussion, namely that about the Uganda project of the English government, led—to the split of the party.