426 as state-specific aspirations. The word, which due to its conciseness is also suited for this, was only meant to indicate the completely changed direction of the new movement compared to before—but not its goal, which was clearly specified by the Zionist authorities themselves. The striving for state independence is not in the essence of the Jewish national idea, but only the striving for the return of the broad strata of the race to primary production, in a closed territory, with opportunities for free cultural development. Not only are ambitions for state independence lacking in the official program, one hears nothing of them even from individual factions. Such ambitions must also vanish immediately with even a brief glance at their own history. There was only one period in the entire long history of ancient Jewry when the land was completely happy for many generations, —that was at the time when it was a mere satrapy of the great Persian Empire.* The individual phases of Zionism are known through the breadth of its agitation. The success of this agitation, however, in no way corresponded to its energy. All Zionist funds together, in more than a decade full of the most strenuous, enthusiastic, and world-spanning activity, could not manage to amass 10 million Francs in assets.
- Besides, small states have rarely prospered. For the large states they are small change, for their own inhabitants a permanent hindrance due to the greater danger, the greater burden of all costs, and the narrowness of their scope. They are dependent on the military and trade-political grace of their neighbors. The miserable situation of the small Balkan states is too well known. But even rich Holland could be almost destroyed by a whim of England with the passage of the Navigation Act, it could later be simply pocketed by Napoleon, and it could now do not the slightest thing for its kinsmen in the Transvaal. Of Portugal and Denmark it is said once a year that they are thinking of selling their colonial possessions. What the petty squirearchy meant for Germany is still remembered. As a rule, small countries result in national and economic stagnation internally and are a defenseless prey for powerful opponents in any historical catastrophes. An independent “Jewish state” would be blown away by the wind.
