Ignaz Zollschan · The Racial Problem · 1912
278printed page
scan 330 of 568

278 sense, and for the majority of our "brilliant" politicians, merchants, artists, and scholars, this is also true. But between true, genuine genius and talent there is another, much more essential difference, which, as an immovable shibboleth, separates the two by a deep chasm. This is the union of this most highly potentiated talent with the depth of thought and feeling that has always distinguished the true initiators of great cultural epochs. In the search for an understanding of these qualities, the theory of heredity also points us in the right direction.

The intellectual faculties of the individual, which are always to be regarded as a dowry of the race, determine the form and measure of his power of thought, which on the one hand adheres to the given content of perception and experience, and on the other hand shows the invincible striving to rise from the particular and subordinate to the most general, supreme principles, to bring the totality of thoughts into a comprehensive context. In this distinction, common parlance is accustomed to differentiating the former type as rationalistic intelligence and the second type as productive intelligence. It is clear that truly cultural work presupposes both types of thought-forms. To the former falls the associative elaboration within the given limits; to the second, higher-value form of thought, however, in which a portion of instinctive driving force is always still present, falls the deepening into the material, the going beyond the limits, the new creation of values. In short, we encounter here a contrast such as is known to us from the mutual relationship between talent and genius.

For example, applied to our specific case, it is said—in large part correctly—that the Jews are very rich in ordinary "intelligence," that this sufficiently explains their proficiency in social life, the resourcefulness of Jewish merchants, the better successes of Jewish pupils. While they may be richer in intelligence, however, they seem to be poorer than other outstanding peoples with respect to the very highest forms of intellect.