Moritz Güdemann · National Judaism · 1897
25printed page
scan 29 of 52
Facsimile · scan 29 of 52
Scan of p. 25
English · AI translation, not yet checked

— 25 —

suffers, is a fact confirmed by world history, which is also repeated in the history of the people of Israel. Therefore, the Pentateuch so often contains the call for Israel to separate itself from the other peoples, not to walk in their ways, nor to follow their example, and so forth. One would be mistaken to see in these admonitions and warnings a contradiction to the task given to Israel: to work towards the merging of the peoples. Rather, this task is thereby confirmed, for, as we have already noted, the emphasis on national individuality, the development of a nativistic national consciousness, was indeed the fundamental feature of the aspirations of the ancient peoples, and Israel was certainly to be warned against this by those admonitions to separate just as urgently as against the religious and moral aberrations of those peoples.

How necessary this was can be seen in the founding of the kingdom, to which Israel, according to its own declaration (I Sam. 8, 5 ff.), was led only by the example of the other peoples. The kingdom, as the most natural expression of the national egoism that pushes for the development of earthly power and greatness, was never conducive to Israel's higher destiny; it therefore always found in the prophetic office a barely concealed opposition, a continuous marginal correction, so to speak, the like of which is not found a second time in history. Just as Samuel only reluctantly consented to the appointment of a king, so Hosea also exclaims (13, 10 ff.): "Where is now thy king, that he may save thee in all thy cities? And thy judges, of whom thou saidst, Give me a king and princes? I gave thee a king in my anger, I will take him away