Vladimir Jabotinsky · On Jews, Russia, and Nationalism: Early Writings of Vladimir Jabotinsky · 1922
247printed page
scan 248 of 279
Facsimile · scan 248 of 279
Scan of p. 247
English · AI translation, not yet checked

recognized as full-fledged states, and if they were to be against slavery, they would crush the South. Therefore, the South wanted to "infect" them, to make them slave-owning states. A difficult constitutional dispute arose. Northerners insisted that since the territories belonged to the Union as such, the Union had the right to prohibit slavery in them. Southerners replied: since the territories belong to the entire Union, southerners have the same right as northerners to settle there with all their property; a southerner's legally acquired property includes negroes, and no one has the right to take away this part of his living inventory when he brings it to the frontier, which is the property of the entire Union. But the conflict could not stop there. From "Uncle Tom's Cabin" we all remember that a negro who crossed the river from Kentucky to Ohio became free. Southerners insisted that this arrangement was legally equivalent, let's say, to permitting horse theft. If the Union constitution recognizes that Kentucky's law on slavery has the force of law, then Uncle Tom is the property of Mr. Legree in the eyes of the entire Union. If Uncle Tom has run away, it is the Union's business to return him to his master, not to hide him while declaring: what's fallen from the cart is lost. Either abolish slavery, or recognize its consequences.

This argument proved to be particularly persuasive. Legal doctrinairism was always a weakness (or a strength?) of American political thought: it is evident in every paragraph of the 1787 constitution, and in the correspondence of President Wilson with Germany. Between these two moments stands the year 1850, when the federal parliament of the United States passed a law according to which fugitive negroes, even in the territory of the northern states, were henceforth subject to detention and return to their masters' embrace. Of course, this led to even greater bitterness, to bloody brawls on the streets of the North with every attempt to detain a runaway negro and, finally, together with all the other causes—to war.

247