Of course, only in the field of science. The question is posed completely differently (as already noted above) in the realm of politics. For the politician and the jurist—the decisive factor for establishing national identity in disputed cases is only one psychological element: the presence of national self-consciousness. To this point of view, by the way, philosophers and psychologists sometimes also adhere. Renan, Lazarus, Fröbel, Mancini, Bluntschli, Jellinek, etc. unanimously agree that a nation is a will. But for the researcher, who is interested not only in the facts and needs of today's political life or in psychological phenomena, but also in objective root causes, the 'nation' will ultimately, after subtracting all sorts of layers conditioned by history, climate, the surrounding nature, and foreign influences—be reduced to its racial basis.
Now let us approach the question with which we began: will there ever be one flock and one shepherd? This is a question of prognosis, and in sociology, the word prognosis means, in essence, fortune-telling; and if any sort of certainty is possible in these divinations, it is not regarding what will be, but rather regarding what will not. For example, one can only believe that there will someday be universal peace on earth. I personally believe this, I believe it very much, though I would not undertake to prove it. But it is clear that for this, the merging and mixing of nations into a single homogeneous blend is not at all required. Peace and harmony are entirely conceivable on the basis of the peaceful coexistence of the most diverse cultures side by side. In general, wars have occurred not because of national differences, but because of economic interests. The national psyche encourages healthy peoples only to create, with their every step and thought, a national culture; but if one rushes to rob a neighbor, the impulse comes not from its national characteristics, but from its economic appetites. Of course, in this act too, the national psyche will manifest itself one way or another, if only in the form of so-called temperament; presumably, even the way it wages war—
172
