The Maccabaean
Jews of Palestine cannot provide any large part of these funds themselves, they must come from the Diaspora.
To buy the land and to provide the utilities for making it productive, directly or indirectly (including in time afforestation of land acquired and perhaps even harbor facilities), such large contributions from Jews of the Diaspora will, for the immediate future and for many years indeed, be indispensable. These contributions may properly take the form of investment in stock, like that in the Jewish Colonial Trust or the Zion Commonwealth, as in that form no obligation of paying a return would be incurred. But the contributions must not take the form of investment or bonds bearing interest, because interest cannot be earned for a long time to come and could be paid only from new contributions. We must not make any representations, expressed or implied, that any return by way of dividends may be expected soon on the stock to be issued. The obligation assumed must be limited to the assumption of the duty to expend the money wisely and efficiently, i. e., in a proper capital outlay in the best possible manner and with the greatest possible economy. If such an expenditure of the funds is made, the outlay will be a good investment. That is, one from which the Jewish people, and eventually individual owners of the shares of stock also, may hope to receive a proper return.
Besides acquisition of land and the installation of recognized indispensable public utilities and afforestation, there is a wide field for contribution by Jews of the Diaspora of funds to be treated as capital investments.
(1) Financial Institutions. Credit for the development of landed enterprises as well as industrial and commercial enterprises and municipal undertakings, is not so clearly dependent upon community action as furnishing credit for the installation of essential public utilities; but community, as distinguished from private, institutions for providing such credit will be of great service in furthering the development which is our objective. Such a community provision will lighten the necessary interest burden; it will tend to prevent discrimination in the grant of credit, and better insure its being granted for purposes subserving the desired development; and it will also tend to avert that hostility to capitalists which arises from the control by private individuals and concerns of the sources of credit. Included in the proper field for the granting of temporary credits are the consumers and producers co-operatives.
This in general is the service which the Jewish Colonial Trust and the Anglo-Palestine Company undertook to render, and have in part rendered, heretofore. They are unable to continue to render these services adequately now; partly because their capital is inadequate; partly because a large part of the existing capital is tied up in loans to the Zionist Organization or the Zionist Commission; partly because it is tied up in real estate and real estate loans.
The working capital of the Jewish Colonial Trust and the Anglo-Palestine Company should be increased so as to enable them to supply the demand for short-time commercial and industrial loans. This must be done in part by the increase of capital issues; in part by paying off the Zionist Organization and the Zionist Commission loans; and in part by disposing of the real estate and real estate loans. To these ends there should be: (a) A sale of new Jewish Colonial Trust and Anglo-Palestine shares
of stock. (b) Cash funds should be raised to pay off the existing Zionist Organization and Zionist Commission indebtedness. (c) A land and mortgage bank should be created to purchase the immobile assets of the Anglo-Palestine Company and to make proper real estate loans in the future. The sale of shares in such land and mortgage bank, like the sales of shares in the Jewish Colonial Trust and the Anglo-Palestine Company, may properly absorb a large amount of money, and on such shares a dividend should be earned and a modest one paid from the start—the balance of earnings being used to build up a surplus.
(2) There is pressing need in the towns, in order that newcomers in commerce and industry may be housed, that very modest dwellings be constructed. This should be done on land acquired for the Jewish people. The cost of building such houses now is much greater than it probably will be a few years' hence, owing to war inflation and primitive conditions of the country. If men are to be housed in buildings constructed under present conditions and must pay now and forever after rent sufficient to meet interest and sinking fund charges, the rent will be prohibitively high. A part of the cost of necessary new buildings may properly be treated as a war expense because it is due to temporary conditions and it is proper that this extra expense be borne as such by the Jews of the Diaspora. In other words, the return on their investment may properly be less than a fair return made today. There may properly be expected a very small return thereon, by way of a dividend on shares of stock, representing the cost of these urban dwellings so constructed. But it should be made clear in selling such stock that the houses so constructed will have to compete in renting later with houses to be built under conditions when building will cost much less in pounds and when the cost of money, measured at the current rate of interest, will be much lower. The building investment may be compared with that now being made by the London County Council.
(3) Educational facilities and research institutions. These, likewise, may properly be aided by contributions from the Diaspora for expenditures, both as capital outlay and for running expenses. The research incident to a new country—the knowledge of its resources, its possibilities, defects and diseases and how to deal with them—is absolutely an expense proper to be borne by the community. It is an outlay demanded by a prudent administration of the Government. It should properly be borne by the Government of Palestine. But many new countries cannot afford such prudent expenditures, i. e., cannot bear the burden of taxation which would be involved in providing by taxation of a sparse and struggling population to the extent required to meet cost of such research. Poverty in such cases may compel a country to be wastefully ignorant. Moneys for this purpose must, unless there is to be a very slow growth of the desired knowledge of local conditions and needs, be provided from without.
To a certain extent money required for educating individuals, particularly in higher education and for vocational training, may properly be so provided also. But
