The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXIV, No. 4 · November 1920
133printed page
scan 33 of 44

Gleanings and Echoes of the Press

More about the London Conference

Both Mr. Sokolow and Mr. Usishkin gave expression to their opinions of the London Conference and more particularly with regard to the American delegation. Mr. Sokolow granted an interview which was printed in the Hatzfirah of Warsaw. When asked regarding the crisis said to have arisen as a result of the attitude of the Americans, he said:

"The truth of the matter is that what is generally understood by the term crisis is totally unknown to us. What we do suffer from is an ailment which is at present common to all countries and all governments and that is a shortage of money. With regard to this question of money we are to a certain extent dependent upon the Zionist Federation of America, and at this point I must emphasize that the American Zionists do not come to us with any demand for radical changes in our policy. They have no desire to establish new Zionist principles. They merely want that we should cut down expenses in so far as possible in those directions which are not immediately concerned with the work of colonization in Palestine.

Mr. Sokolow denies that there is an inner crisis in the organization and maintains that the whole question resolves itself into one of money. He explains the point of view of the Americans in the following manner:

The Americans desire to restrict the budget for the Palestine schools. They also desire to introduce a measure of economy in the London office. The American Zionists must take into account the opinions of the Jewish public in America, the public which contributes the money. This public is accustomed to hear only of big things. One must ever come to them with great promises and exaggerated announcements. They have been accustomed to this. The large Jewish masses in America cannot conceive the tremendous importance of our Hebrew schools in Palestine and will not admit that large sums of Zionist money should be spent for the maintenance of these schools. The opinion is held in America that the Zionist Organization is called upon to spend its money only for purposes of colonization, only for that sort of work which will enlarge the settlement, increase our possession of the soil and bring us nearer to an actual administration of the country.

Mr. Usishkin took issue with the Americans while delivering a report of the Conference at a meeting of the "Vaad Hazmani." His point was that Zionists must devote their energies to work in the Diaspora as well as in Palestine.

He criticised the attitude of the Americans that everything in Palestine must be done on a basis of "business" and their demands that the budget of the schools be restricted. He made this defense of the Zionist Commission:

Behind the scenes the Zionist Commission was accused of being terribly wasteful and all sorts of tales were related about their extravagance, but it was found necessary to even question the members of the Zionist Commission on the subject. After the Conference I discussed this with Brandeis at great length. I told him: "You are a judge and it was your duty to act differently, if you really wanted to get at the truth. You invited Weizmann, Nordau, Saphir and Rosenblatt. Why did you not see fit also to invite me, the accused. He excused himself and there the matter ended. But I will demand of the National Assembly to appoint a committee which should thoroughly investigate the work of the Zionist Commission. It should be remembered that if mistakes were made by the Commission, and if there were extravagance, it was due to the heirdom which was bequeathed to us by those Americans who were at the head of the Commission for some time."

Mr. Usishkin expressed the optimistic view that the differences with the Americans would finally be adjusted. He related that he had said the following to Mr. Brandeis:

"I have greater faith in American Jewry than you have and other parts of the world will also come to our assistance. Our differences of opinion are not so serious. We must show a united front against those who differ from us entirely. The National Assembly is coming into existence at a most approaching moment. But you must be on guard and see that this gathering is not converted into a repetition of the London Conference."

Amid the criticism which is being hurled at them, the Americans have undertaken upon their return from the Conference to clarify their attitude at the Conference and to effect a change in the American organization which would lead to better understanding with the Zionists of Europe and more intensive work in Palestine. The Executive Committee, at its meeting of September 29th and 30th, adopted the following resolutions:

The London Conference has made clear that a new epoch in Zionism began with the San Remo decision and the appointment of the High Commissioner of the British Government in Palestine. The era of education on behalf of Zionism has passed over into the period of constructive work in Palestine. Our primary duty in America is to devote effort of every kind to the imperatively urgent tasks which we face in the upbuilding of the Jewish Homeland in Palestine.

In all our labors, it is our most earnest desire to preserve the integrity of the International Zionist Organization and to continue to lend all co-operation and participation that will heighten its effectiveness in the service of the Jewish Homeland in Palestine. This Organization will continue its support of the International Zionist Organization in such measure as shall be determined by the Zionist Organization or by its National Executive.

Further, it is our duty to proceed at once to such a reorganization of the Zionist Organization of America as will enable it to meet the conditions that have arisen in Palestine. All expenditures of the Organization outside of Palestine must be reduced to a minimum and in order that this may be done, it is necessary to simplify the work so as to make possible its concentration upon the one great task. A Commission of Five or Seven on reorganization shall be appointed. This Commission shall be in continuous session. It shall hear all who ought to be or may wish to be heard. It shall report to the National Executive at a special meeting to be called within 30 days and prior to the submission of the plan as it may be amended to the Annual Convention.

With reference to the Koron Hayisod our judgment is that inasmuch as no definite plans have been drawn by the International Executive or its representatives at this time a consideration of the entire subject may be postponed until complete data be at hand. In the meantime, we propose to proceed with the specific tasks in Palestine, including the Palestinian Government Loan in most effective co-operation with the International Zionist Organization of which we are a part. And to this end we ask for the full support of all American Jews.

A Committee shall be appointed to determine the immediate activities to be undertaken in Palestine and to consider the whole question of the Koron Hayisod.

We suggest that the objectives in the development of a Jewish Palestine as outlined in a memorandum drawn up by Justice Brandeis shall guide the Committee on Reorganization and the Committee on Palestine work in their deliberations.

And while it has become essential for the Organization as such to concentrate its activities upon the enormously difficult problem of upbuilding Palestine, it is the duty of all Jews to continue their interest in and support of every rightful effort to ameliorate the lot of Jews in all lands.

Dr. Wise, Chairman of the Special Committee, further offered in behalf of his committee, the recommendation that a Committee of