The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXIV, No. 4 · November 1920
127printed page
scan 27 of 44

The Maccabaean

Zionists by no means discouraged, that money was the least of our worries, that given the facilities for work we shall never want for the means to carry out the work, can only be imagined. The immediate effect, however, is most serious, because in the panic-stricken economy which is being enforced, it is difficult, in considering the suspension of activities, to distinguish between essential and non-essential enterprises.

It is those who see only the immediate effect that take the depressing view of the present curtailment and partial suspension spelling financial ruin and moral bankruptcy. Their contention is that the American Organization, and for that matter any other organization, is justified in demanding the most drastic changes in policy and personnel, but that no Zionist body should approach the Palestine task with anything like reservations, and condition its active or passive participation on the fulfillment of those demands; that the present Palestine commitments are not those of the Zionist Commission, but of the Zionist Organization, the Jewish people's agency; that if there has been extravagance in Palestine, the persons who are responsible for it, and not the work, ought to be made to suffer; that, finally, it is highly dangerous to change horses in mid-stream, and any changes must be made with caution and care if panic and disaster are to be forestalled.

The hysteria is increased by the fact that the relief funds management is now quite separated from the general funds, the Joint Distribution Committee having appointed Dr. Pool as the Palestine Relief Director, thus depriving the Zionist Commission of considerable sums which it could apply to constructive relief, as was the case when Dr. Pool administered the J. D. C. moneys through what was nominally the Relief Department of the Zionist Commission. Another serious blow to the Zionist Commission's prestige is the actual and substantial severing of the American Zionist Medical Unit, under the directorship of Miss Szold, from the Zionist Commission, a tie which while never more than formal, gave the Zionist Commission the right to exert a certain moral influence over the "Hadassah" work.

The saner view is, of course, that the conditions which brought to the turning point are all to the good, that American Zionism, conscious of its sacred trust, may possibly repudiate this or that obligation, but it will never renounce Palestine; that it is just as well for these differences to have arisen now at the beginning of the work; that before long America will acknowledge that the Jewish National Home is the Jewish people's task, and not so much that of the Mandatory, and that after this common understanding the Palestine work will, indeed, take a new course, America leading as heretofore.

History and Legend in Palestine

IN Palestine we are making history; we are also making legends. That proves we are a live people, a real folk.

There are no longer "old" and "new" Jews in Jerusalem; at last we are unified, one folk with one vision, one striving. The riots of Passover first clearly showed us this truth. It was the orthodox Jews who began, on the last day of Passover, to write their signatures in the synagogue, in protest against the arrest of our Self-Defense men. The collections for the Fund of Redemption again proved us one people with one hope and one striving. The coming of Sir

Herbert Samuel as the Governor of Palestine has united us as nothing else. I have yet to hear the Jew who does not appreciate the greatness and the meaning of that event. Even an assimilationist like Anna Landau admits that wonders are happening, although illogically, she will not admit that the Zionists have helped to bring them about. It is the work of God, and she will not see who are God's instruments. Of course, the Zionists are satisfied. But the greatest marvel in the whole series of events is the way the orthodox community of Jerusalem accepts Samuel as its leader and as the first sign of redemption. He is called only by his Jewish name, Eliezer ben Menachem, and he is believed to be the forerunner of the true Messiah. Messiah ben David is still to come. But among the orthodox Jews and the simple people Samuel is known by only one name, Messiah ben Joseph.

There is no doubt of it. It is in the books, they say, in the Zohar. The time has been figured out, and this is the year and that was the day—the day on which he came—when Messiah ben Joseph was to appear.

Wonderful stories are told of how Samuel rises before dawn every morning and has a minyon of orthodox men join him at Government House in prayer. It is said that these men are secretly driven up in a blue and white automobile, and are then driven home again, Samuel has been scrupulously correct in matters Jewish; he does not work on the Sabbath nor do any of the other Jews in the Government service. He does not ride on the Sabbath. Legend relates that he brought with him a whole kosher kitchen outfit, and that during the early days of his rule a Rabbi took up to Government House enough mezuzot for all the doors.

When Samuel arrived, and when first he received the representatives of the various communities here, he did so with the Oriental pomp that is familiar in British India. He wore white robes and a gold band on his head. This outward pomp has satisfied an inward longing. For Samuel looks the Jew, and to the Jew, quite rightly, all this is Jewish, and not British, splendor. Quietly, tactfully, certainly, Samuel has part, and the chief part, of the destiny of all its peoples. And so others take it for granted.

Marvelous stories are being told of happenings at Rachel’s Tomb.

It is said that the gold and jewels collected for the Fund of Redemption were reported to some Arabs to be buried under Rachel’s Tomb. Their worth was said to be a hundred thousand pounds. A group of Arabs surrounded the Tomb in order to rob it, and when the Shamash resisted them they tried to assault him. Suddenly there rose out of the Tomb a beautiful, slim young woman, clothed in long, flowing garments of snowy white, with jewels about her throat and with a halo of light about her head. This was no other than Mother Rachel. She waved her hand, and the hands and feet of all the Arabs were instantly withered, so that they could not move. She then beckoned to the Shamash to follow her, and she led him into the Tomb, down into long, dark caverns. The only light that guided them: was the halo about her head. At last they emerged into an open space, where there was a great mountain of gold. -

"This," said Mother Rachel, "is all the gold that the Jews have brought throughout the ages as an offering to their people."

She waved her hand, and the mountain was split in two.

November, 1920

One Hundred Twenty-seven