The Maccabaean
The complex of the International Zionist Conference had still other phases. One of these, also a development of the war, is the extremist view of the principle of nationality —the application of the theory of Jewish nationality, the rights of the Jewish nation, as such, in the diaspora, the use of the Zionist Organization in the maintenance and development of these rights. This implies the organization of Jews for the election, as Zionists, of municipal, provincial and State officials; for the setting up of a complete government for Jewish affairs, religious, philanthropic and even sociological, which shall be independent of the general government of the land, or with a liaison officer in the Cabinet and sharing in the budget of the country (perhaps, also, to be vested with taxing-powers). To the Zionists who hold this extreme nationalist view Palestine is a secondary issue, or rather the ultimate. The paramount consideration is the present—“das gegenwart”—and in the name of Jewish culture they have specific demands to press upon the Conference, particularly financial; demands for the establishment of schools and teachers, seminaries which will serve to arouse the Jewish consciousness of the diaspora-enslaved masses. And the strongest argument of these Zionists is that one cannot expect a Jewish development in Palestine unless the Jews of the diaspora undergo a Jewish development.
One can understand the development of this extremist view, and the advocacy by those who have had to face Jewish life as it has had to be lived in Europe, even before the war. Among other things that Zionism is, it is also the antidote to assimilation. It is not so very long ago that the realization of the Basle program was a matter of the distant future; it is not so very long ago that all the Zionists could do was to foster a few institutions in Palestine, raise money for the National Fund, buy Colonial Trust shares, encourage the Bezallel School, patronize the Technicum, plan personal migrations to Palestine and lend themselves more or less to an Hebraic renaissance. Meantime the forces of assimilation were pressing hard upon Jewish life and threatening to submerge it. What more natural, then, for Zionists than to utilize the fact that they constituted the only body of organized and conscious Jews to resist the menace of assimilation. From this to the development of a distinct political party is an understandable development, even by those who, like the writer, regard it as an undesirable development. And we can understand, also, why the protagonists of this development look askance upon its opponents.
But meanwhile Palestine itself has become a factor. A generation has grown up there, sons and daughters of the pioneers. Others have gone into the land and become a part of it. Life in Palestine has its own peculiarities, accentuated by the diverse elements that constitute its Jewish population, and these peculiarities affect even sociological outlooks. The difference between Arab and Jewish living standards in Palestine is one of the peculiarities. The sharp conflict between the “old” and the “new” settlements is another. The representatives of the old “Yishub” are distinctly bourgeois; the representatives of the new “Yishub”—journalists, mainly, curiously enough—are decidedly radical, and their chief concerns are the exaltation of labor’s interests and the suppression of private initiative. But even among the radicals there are diverse points of view, coupled with unanimity of criticism against the Zionist Commission.
* * *Passing reference has been made to the “Mizrachi”—one of the two “fractions” which participated in the Vienna
Conference. As constituted then, the “Mizrachi” was composed of a number of Rabbis, enthusiastic Zionists, loyal supporters of the general movement. Their grouping as an entity within the movement was without political motive. They desired nothing more and nothing less than the generality of Zionists. But by their grouping they wished to demonstrate that orthodox Jewry, as such, and orthodox Rabbis, in particular, could and, in fact, must participate in the effort to realize the Herzlian program. If their grouping had any political significance at all, it was external. It was a demonstration against Ihe “protest Rabbiner” who had fulminated against Herzl and his early adherents, and denounced the Zionist movement as opposed to the religion of Israel and its Messianic vision and to the “historic development” of Judaism.
In a measure, the same things may be said of the “Poale Zion,” the other of the fractions represented at the Vienna Congress. They, too, were loyal to the general organization, and their grouping as a separate entity also partook of the nature of a demonstration that there was nothing in general Socialism that made impossible the adherence of Jewish Socialists to the movement to establish in Palestine a national Homeland for the Jewish people.
But seven years, and especially such years as those through which humanity has just passed, work many changes, and among the extraordinary changes that these years have worked some have been in the character of these “fractions.” Both have become political, both have developed sharp points of difference with the general organization, both have built up theories and dogmas, and both have discovered sines qua non—the recognition of which is their price for adhesion to the movement. And still more extraordinary and perplexing is that development which makes it possible for these two “fractions,” which in general life are antipodean, to coalesce, to form a “bloc” as against the conservative elements in the movement.
A shrewd observer, who has just returned from a tour of Poland, states that every Jewish home in that country is divided into as many parties as there are members of a family. This condition reflected itself at the International Conference. New fractions have come into being within the Zionist movement, mainly secessions from the Poale Zion. Thus there were representatives of the Achduth Haavoda, the Hitachduth Hoapoel Hazair-Zeire Zion, Zeire Zion, Hapoel Hazair and Mizrach Verband Zeire Zion. The differences between these fractions—that is their “grund-prinzipien”—and, indeed, the differences between them and their parent, the “Poale Zion,” are so hair-splitting (when they are not lost entirely in a vague welter of words) as to baffle definition. And it is doubtful whether the spokesmen of these fractions are themselves able to make a clear exposition of their fundamentals or to make a satisfactory defense of their right to exist at all within the purview of the Zionist Organization. But there they are (and their number threatens to increase rather than to diminish) and their points of view, pressed with tremendous zeal, add to the bewilderment of the Conference.
In among these diverse elements were also the “veterans” — the survivors of the Zionist movement as it had developed from the first Congress at Basle, in 1897, to the Vienna Congress of 1913—the men who had come into the movement when Herzl had sounded his clarion call to all Israel and who had survived the cleft over Uganda at the Sixth Con-