The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXIV, No. 3 · September 1920
67printed page
scan 3 of 74
Facsimile · scan 3 of 74
Scan of p. 67
Text · transcribed from the scan

The Maccabaean

gration must be abandoned. The masses fleeing from the lands of slaughter in Eastern Europe will not pay regard to any obstacles or any warnings against immigration. There remains, therefore, only one course which our national work must now follow, namely, the organizing of mass-immigration.

A second consideration to be faced is the financial problem. In former days, in our financial schemes regarding Palestine, an important part was played by Jewish capital in the Eastern countries. We know well from abundant instances what great monetary sacrifices Eastern Jewry was ready to make in the past for the restoration of Palestine. But the sums amassed in those countries, in so far as they have not been plundered and dissipated, are at the present European rates of exchange almost valueless. Hence the greater portion of the Jewish people is not in a position to take any serious financial part in the building up of our country. These two facts we have to take into consideration when we come to form our schemes of work for the near future.

The program of our national undertakings, the details of the great public works which it will be possible to execute by means of the sums of money to be mentioned later on all this may be left to our experts and our authorities. Here I should like to say a few words on the difficult problem of our finance and the way to solve it. In order to create in Palestine the necessary conditions for carrying through a yearly immigration into the country of some tens of thousands of Jews, it is necessary, according to the calculations of our experts, to create a fund of twenty-five million pounds sterling. One of the most burning questions for us therefore must be, how can this great sum be raised? For the solving of this problem two main proposals have so far been put forward. One school maintains that the sum can be raised only by means of a national loan; whilst another body of opinion advocates as the only means likely to succeed an appeal for a national voluntary contribution. Let us consider these two proposals.

The idea of a national loan is a natural and logical one for a people which lives on its own soil. Such a people pos sesses numerous assets. It has at its disposal a variety of taxes and other national funds. Mortgaging all these assets or part of them as security or guarantee, a people living under such normal conditions can without difficulty raise national loans; without such guarantees public loans can hardly be raised anywhere. We must, then, ask whether we are in a position to fulfill in Palestine these conditions. A moment's reflection will show that the answer is in the nega tive. Our only national assets in Palestine are at present the pieces of land which are in the possession of the Jewish Na tional Fund. Apart from the fact that the statutes of the Jewish National Fund forbid the mortgaging of its proper ties and farms, their number is too small and they are alto gether inadequate to form the necessary security for any public loan worth mentioning.

One of the most important elements in any national loan is the punctual annual payment of interest. Should we be in a position to fulfill this condition? Even the strongest supporters of the idea of a national loan openly admit that before the lapse of some twenty years we cannot reckon on our possessing the means to pay up the interest, and it is a fact, known to any one who is versed in the history of public loans, that whenever the interest is not paid in the course of

the first ten years, the capital also may then safely be considered as lost

But leaving on one side the question of interest, let us ask whether we shall be able to pay off the capital itself in the course of the first ten years. The answer to this question will also be, No. We must not forget that the first portion of the national loan will have to be applied to undertakings which will not bring in any return in the shape of income and which will simply swallow up large portions of the capital. The large Jewish masses which will immigrate into Palestine will have to bring into cultivation lands hitherto uncultivated, which will only begin to yield their harvests after the lapse of some years. Nor must it be forgotten that we are setting about the reconstruction of the country at a time of great national crisis everywhere, and of conditions of great scarcity, which are bound to have an adverse effect on the capital of the loan. We have to build a vast number of houses for the laborers, we must have an enormous quantity of machinery and working implements, and large quantities of raw material for building and other purposes, all of which have now risen enormously in price. With such huge expenses facing us it will easily be seen what a tremendous responsibility is incurred in applying national moneys to such purposes, no matter how strong are the pledges given for their repayment. The belief that with the magic watchword "national loan" we shall win the ready sympathy of the people and thus quickly obtain the necessary amount, is a mistake. The moneyed Jews will not look seriously upon a proposition which, while calling itself a loan, does not offer to pay any interest. and, as regards the capital, gives only a promise of repayment after a score or more years. They will bring forward all sorts of arguments to show that the whole scheme only aims at raising a small "charity subscription under the mask of a loan which is not to be taken seriously. Such a view and such an attitude on the part of Jewish financial circles is bound to cause great harm to the national work, as well as to the very idea of a national loan which, perhaps, it will not be possible to repair for many years.

The idea of a national loan would certainly be received with enthusiasm among the Jewish masses. The question is only whether it is morally right to collect large sums from the poor Jewish masses on the basis of promises the fulfillment of which cannot be guaranteed.

A national loan we must have eventually, and probably it will be very successful, but the time for it has not yet come; we shall have it after some years, after we have created in our land normal economic conditions. Should we succeed in the course of a few years in creating a fairly large number of economic assets, such as railways, ports, electrical power stations and large cultivated areas—which will belong to the whole Jewish community—then only shall we have the natural and normal conditions which will enable us to raise loans. We shall then have a national estate which we shall be able to offer wholly or partially as guarantee in the same manner as other financially sound and solvent nations. We must thus renounce for the present all the beautiful and romantic national appeals which might be based on the proclamation of a national loan; we must postpone that project for a later period. There now remains for us only a more modest way: to appeal to every Jewish heart, to every Jew who has not yet lost his connection with his people, that he should bring a money-sacrifice for the deliverance of his people. We shall be able to say with perfect truth and a clear con-