The Maccabaean
to adjust himself and to survive under the new conditions, not merely as a means for chronicling the history of a great people whose golden age is already in the past.
The practical motive which animated the writing of the book has nevertheless not detracted from its scientific worth. The material presented and the method of treatment place the book, beyond a shadow of a doubt, on the plane of a scientific treatise. In the first part Dr. Dushkin has created for us, out of the original source material, the history of Jewish education in New York City, which we may consider practically identical with the history of Jewish education in the United States. The layman and professional educator will both be profoundly interested in this narration of the development of the Jewish school in America. It is no dry recital of facts, but an attempt to evaluate the educational efforts of the Jews of America; what is permanent or temporary; what is possible and what impractical, and what the Jewish will to live means in terms of education. Most important, it gives us the perspective by which alone we can judge whether the Jews as a people will live or die in America.
In the second part the technique of the educational survey developed in America has been applied to the field of Jewish education, to unearth for us and to present in organized fashion a great mass of facts concerning the various aspects of Jewish education. The wealth of material comes as a delightful surprjse in a book on J ewish life, for our tendency has been to hang a mountain of generalization on a hair of fact. Fortunately, the main conclusions reached through the accumulation of the vast amount of statistics has been illustrated by impressive diagrams and graphs. Incidentally, af admirable example of what might be done in investigating.the other phases of Jewish life is offered to the prospective student and writer.
Through and above this great mass of facts on school population, grading, curricula, methods, teachers, finances, buildings, etc., there looms one large fact of fundamental interest to all those who are concerned with Jewish life in America. This fact is that the Jews are pitifully behind their task in the problem of Jewish education. Only 25 per cent. of the Jewish children of school age are in Jewish schools at any one time. This seems disheartening enough, but the situation becomes painful when we stop to consider what that is which we call the education of most of the 25 per cent.—what the buildings are like, who the teachers are, what the children learn ultimately, and what loyalty to Jewish life we can expect. Irrespective of one's party or persuasion within Jewish life, Dr. Dushkin points out that all who believe in some kind of Jewish life must be deeply concerned with this negative condition in Jewish education, which, if permitted to continue, spells the disintegration of Jewish life in America. We cannot hold our children through these meagre and inadequate facilities. What alone saves us from discouragement is another equally important fact which the survey makes clear to us, namely, that underneath this inadequate and disorganized provision for Jewish education there is, nevertheless, a strong desire for Jewish education, resting indeed in great part upon traditional momentum, but nevertheless surely present as a source of energy which may be utilized in the upbuilding of a better system of education.
The plea for an extension and improvement of facilities for Jewish education will meet with unanimous approval. It will be in the discussion of methods of solution which touch or depend upon a point of view where disagreement is more likely to arise. Perhaps the strongest opposition will be directed against Dr. Dushkin's attitude toward the parochial school. While not apprehensive of the existence of a small number of parochial schools which we have at present, he is opposed to the extension of the parochial schools as a general method of solving the Jewish educational problem. Dr. Dushkin maintains that the parochial school is opposed to one of the fundamental principles of American education, namely, the idea that general elementary education must be public. He believes, too, that the American Jew does not want to send his children to a parochial school. In addition, a system of parochial schools is impractical, for the burden of expense involved in the erection and maintenance of separate schools where both secular and Jewish subjects will be
taught is far beyond what can be expected of the American Jewish community. Dr. Dushkin will also find opponents to his position with reference to the place of Hebrew in the curriculum. Here, too, as in the case of the parochial school, it will be necessary to guard against a misunderstanding. Dr. Dushkin believes, of course, that Hebrew ought to be the central subject in any adequate Jewish school. Nevertheless, some subjects may at some time be taught more efficiently in English, and in such cases he would retain the use of English. The bulk of the time, however, Dr. Dushkin holds, ought to be devoted to the teaching of Hebrew, Bible and Hebrew literature. He points out, furthermore, that for various reasons all Jewish children cannot be expected to have the advantage of an intensive Jewish training, and for these much good work can be done through an English curriculum. We might state his position simply by saying that he would use English to supplement, not supplant, the instruction in Hebrew. There are undoubtedly a number of smaller matters, especially in the more technical discussion, which will not meet with unanimity of opinion. Perhaps, too, some will feel that the book has been unduly influenced by the Bureau of Education, of which it is an expression. On the whole, however, all will agree that Dr. Dushkin has endeavored to give an impartial and non-partisan survey of the problem of Jewish education, and will welcome the work as a distinct contribution to the fundamental problem in the task of perpetuating Jewish life in this country.
The book remains as an invaluable source of suggestion both for the professional Jewish teacher, principal and educational administrator. Indeed, it is more than a collection of data and ideas. It offers a challenge to the Jewish community. It contains enough information and suflcient ideas to guide the development of Jewish education for a decade, perhaps for a generation. Dr. Dushkin’s work may remain a chronicle or a living force—that depends upon the wisdom of our communal leaders and the vitality of the American Jewish community. J. D. H.
J. D. H.
RIETMANN PILCER COMPANY
Shipping and Forwarding Agents
29 BROADWAY, NEW YORK
'Phone, 272-273 Whitehall
Official Forwarders for the Zionist Organization of America
Unexcelled facilities for shipping direct to Palestine, freight and merchandise of every nature.
Our twenty-five years of experience in forwarding merchandise and goods of every description to all parts of the world, specializing in shipments to the NEAR EAST and PALESTINE assure our clients the best service and a saving in money, time and annoyance.
We are regularly Licensed Insurance Brokers, guaranteeing to our clients lowest prices on all risks against war, fire, transportation thefts and pilferage.
CUSTOM HOUSE BROKERS
Customs business of every kind promptly and carefully transacted
