The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXIV, No. 3 · September 1920
94printed page
scan 30 of 74

The Maccabaean

In answer to the above letter, the Barid al Yom of June 17th printed the following reply, signed by five Mukhtars and forty-eight Sheikhs:

We, the undersigned, Sheikhs and Mukhtars of the villages, have read a letter of our representative, Sheikh Ahmad Ibrahim Abu Gosh, in the Barid al Yom, and we hereby declare that we approve of it, that his words are true and just, and anybody acquainted with the situation in the villages and laboring for the benefit of the country will confirm this statement. We thank our Sheikh for this letter, which has brought us comfort and succor. We have heard, however, that the statement of Abu Gosh has evoked the resentment of certain effendis, who accuse him of serving the Zionists for money. Allah!

We hereby testify that the words of this free man are true, that our representative, Sheikh Ibrahim, is an honest man, a descendant of a noble family known as the protector of the rights and interests of the fellah, and very wealthy besides, and has consequently no reason to sell his soul to the Zionists for money. We beg of the effendis to stop this libellous cant. The time of the glory of the effendis has passed, and the villages will no longer be ruled by them. They place their faith in Allah and will not halt in their career of development and prosperity of the country. No longer shall the country be barren and devastated. Let the effendis take care of their urban interests and leave us alone. The villagers have men amongst them who look after the interest of the inhabitants and who work for their benefit and peace.

Rabbi Heller and the Central Conference of American Rabbis

In the last number of THE MACCABAEAN Rabbi Heller took the Conference to task for its anti-Zionist resolution. In a signed editorial in the Kansas City Jewish Chronicle Rabbi Harry H. Mayer comments upon what he terms Rabbi Heller's "undignified argument." Rabbi Mayer makes no attempt at a rejoinder, saying:

With the general line of argument that he pursues we shall not deal in this place. He can be refuted easily, but nothing will be gained by a refutation. The thing to which we take particular exception in his article is the line of argument that he follows in order to discredit the majority vote of the Conference, he having been one of the minority.

Rabbi Mayer then follows with what he might by implica tion term "dignified argument":

Rabbi Heller must be criticised for the violent intemperateness of his language in the article which he has written for the August MACCABAEAN. He makes charges against the Conference majority which an Anti-Semite would be condemned for employing. He accuses the majority of unfairness, intolerance, pettiness, factionalism, wrangling, muzzling the other side, choking off discussion, suppressing speech, materialism, blindness because their eyes are "accustomed only to the hard glare of the commonplace world of practical trivialities;" "too dull to perceive the glows of spiritual beauty, or, beneath them the deeps of divine mystery," bickering, railing skepticism, criticasters, distorters of the truth, and similar choice epithets are some of the brickbats he hurls.

He betrays the weakness of his own side of the question by stooping to the level of denunciation against his brother rabbis. An Anti-Semite can find abundant material in Rabbi Heller's atrabilious effusion to supply him with proofs of the spiritual inferiority, the time-serving mercenariness and the lamentable worldliness of the spiritual leaders of American Reform Jewish congregations. He is miffed and in his peevishness he will not even concede that his side is truly beaten. He solemnly affirms that his opponents' triumph is a Pyrrhic victory. His opponents, if they cared to retort to him in the language he affects, might say that he is fouling his own nest. Verily the destroyers of Israel are not the Henry Fords and Drumonts, but the Rabbi Hellers, who bite the hand that has fed them.

Future Policies of the Jewish Congress

(Continued from page 82)

an organization on a democratic basis which will benefit themselves as well as the Jews abroad, and which will abolish the chaos in local as well as in national American Jewish life.

Adhering to the traditions of the old Congress, the Provisional Committee failed to take advantage of an opportunity to show American Jewry why the Congress was a necessity. Such an opportunity was furnished by the recent outbreak of anti-Semitic propaganda in this country. While the extent of the propaganda was not so serious as to warrant cause for alarm, it was nevertheless urgent to counteract it in a sufficiently effective manner so as to leave no trace of it. But whose job was it? The Anglo-Jewish press has no voice and the attempts of several provincial weeklies to do it were praiseworthy but inadequate. The Anti-Defamation League of the Bnai Brith made a bid for the champion's rôle, but it fell short of its task. It occurred to few people that the proper agency to deal with a matter of this kind was the American Jewish Congress. The idea did not occur to the present leaders of the Congress, and if they did have the idea the psychology of the old Congress prevented them from putting it into action. The Central Conference of American Rabbis thought there should be a central agency to deal with a problem like anti-Semitism, but the Conference, of course, would not concede this power to the American Jewish Congress.

The case of Sir Stuart Samuel's report on the Polish pogroms not being able to find room in the English newspapers until The Day published it as a paid advertisement in the New York Times, was another instance calling for action on the part of the Congress. It was vital that the American people should know that the protests against the Poles were justified, and that the cry of pogroms was not exaggerated. But when the American newspapers, deliberately or otherwise, overlooked the official verdict pronouncing the guilt of the Polish Government, it was the business of the Congress to make that fact known. It is true that Mr. Richards, the Secretary of the Congress, did make it a point to furnish the material to the newspapers and finally induced the Nation to publish the report. But the directness and authority which should characterize the actions of the Congress as the representative of American Jewry was lacking, and it will be generally little known that the Congress had even moved a finger in the whole matter.

True enough, it requires a great deal of money for the Congress to carry on the extensive publicity necessary in the exercising of its functions. This money would be forthcoming if the Jews of America realized that the Congress was necessary as a permanent institution for American activities and was not a temporary organization, the need for which had passed with the war.

In order to arouse the interest of the Jewish masses in the forthcoming elections for delegates to the Congress, the Committee must make a clear and definite statement of the aims of the Congress and what the Congress proposed to do in America. The old Congress had lost the confidence of American Jewry. It will be difficult for the Committee to regain that confidence for the new Congress unless it informs the Jews of America, in positive terms, what the Congress will accomplish for them.