The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXIV, No. 3 · September 1920
93printed page
scan 29 of 74
Facsimile · scan 29 of 74
Scan of p. 93
Text · transcribed from the scan

The Maccabaean

New York and other cities published extensive cables referring to it. Despite its sensational and official character, and despite the large Jewish population in the city of New York, the English-language papers of New York City at first printed nothing about the report. The Associated Press sent no dispatch regarding the report. The secretary of the American Jewish Congress, Mr. Bernard G. Richards, thereupon wrote to friends of his connected with two New York city newspapers, which wrote to the Associated Press on July 9 inquiring whether it had received any dispatch on the subject. The superintendent of the Associated Press foreign service, Mr. Charles T. Thompson, replied on July 16 that the Associated Press had received nothing, but that, upon hearing of the interest in the report, he had cabled the London office of the Associated Press, and had "received a copy of which I enclose herewith."

It so happened that this "summary" was totally inaccurate. It was a quotation of editorial opinion of the London Times.

But, continues The Nation:

When the full text of the Samuel report reached this country, certain Jewish agencies made it available to all the New York newspapers; two of them printed parts of it. All of the papers, however, found space on July 27 for a denial by Prince Lubomirski, the Polish Minister to this country, that the Poles had recently committed excesses against the Jews; the denial was largely an attack upon the Bolsheviki. The New York Times printed this Lubomirski statement; it did not print the second and correct Associated Press summary of the Samuel report sent out the same day. The publisher of the Day, a Jewish-language newspaper printed in New York, then offered the Times an opportunity to print the Samuel report in full. The Times, we are informed, refused, denying its news value. The Day thereupon paid the Times to print the Samuel report as an advertisement.

Catholic Opposition to Zionism

Unlike the sentiments expressed by the Pope some years ago to Mr. Sokolow, there is now coming to the surface a clear-cut opposition on the part of leading Catholics to the idea of Palestine as a Jewish National Homeland. Recently the National Catholic Congress was held at Liverpool and Cardinal Bourne, Archbishop of Westminster, dealt at length with the subject of Palestine, and was apprehensive regarding the outlook of his church in Palestine now that "a new non-Christian influence was being deliberately set up in the land whence countless generations of Christendom had longed and striven to oust a non-Christian power."

To which Palestine replies:

Is not the word “influence,” as used by his Eminence, in need of explanation and definition? Influence may be quantitative or qualitative. Quantitatively, Christian influence in Palestine may be increased either by immigration or by conversion of the existing population. Both methods are open, the first as well as the second, now as before, although as a matter of fact Palestine offer little, if any, attraction to any other than Jewish immigrants, who alone are prepared to make the necessary sacrifices. But it is the qualitative influence which really matters to Christianity, not the quantitative, the capacity of Palestine to assist spiritual revitalization. We should have thought it was unquestionabie that Zionism heightens this capacity infinitely. It is from a Jewish national Palestine that the world has derived the spiritual treasures it has drawn from. Palestine.

Sheikh and Effendi

Arabian villages around Jerusalem are protesting against the anti-Zionist agitation. The following letter repudiating the effendis appeared in the Barid al Yom of June 8th, from

Sheikh Ahmad Ibrahim Abu Gosh, chief of the Sheikhs of the villages in the neighborhood of Jerusalem:

To all Sheikhs and Mukhtars of the Villages:

VB all DULIELS aUuU WLURLLAEO VA Wu EDEN I, the undersigned, was one of those who approved and signed the letter. submitted to His Excellency the Chief Administrator of Occupied Enemy Territory (South), in which we gave expression to what our duty dictated, to what our sane commonsense pointed out to us, and to what our aspirations demand for the peace and settlement of our land. We asked therein that the Mandate for our Motherland be entrusted to the noble and fair-desaling Government of Great Britain, to rule over our cities. This we did, especially when we saw the machinations of certain of the effendis of the towns, and how they strained every nerve to ruin everything that possessed the power to benefit our wretched country, so that they might obtain all the best positions, be the leaders of councils and lord it over the land and its inhabitants. All they desired was to see the land waste and poor, barren and without resource, and from her helplessness to extract profit for themselves. The fellah knows at last their frustrated plans and their unrealized ambitions. We therefore address these our words to the men of the villages, who are the backbone of our land, the source of its prosperity, and the cornerstone of its settlement, to the men who suffered in the olden times all manner of burden and degradation at the hands of those who arrogated to themselves the title “Highest in the Land,” to the men who were despoiled and rendered unhappy, slaves against their will, mere tools in the hands of their plunderers, unable to raise their necks, until the very land was destroyed and its dwellers perished. The country became backward, poverty stalked throughout its bounds, famine wrought desolation, all the riches of the villages and the earnings of the fellahin went into the pockets of the effendis, who on these ruins piled up their wealth. . \

Men of the villages, you have been exploited enough. You have been ill-treated and insulted enough. Everyone who knows your condition recognizes that those who are trying to convert themselves into your masters are nothing but the origin of your exhaustion and the cause of your lowliness. When we appealed to you to help us to consummate that policy which could free you from your chains of iron, you strengthened our hands and supported us, nor refused us your signatures and approval. Then we ‘wrote our declarations whereon were founded your weal and wealth, and we handed them into the proper quarters. And soon you will see the results which will be the beginning of a new era. You will be the masters and not those men who robbed you of your rights and tyrannized over your resources and your money. We are confident that you still retain your opinion on these matters whence depend your prosperity and your advantage. Therefore do not heed those same effendis and their agents who thresten you in order to keep you in blindness and folly so that they may not lose the moneys which they amass from your ruination, from the labor of your hands and the sweat of your brow.

The British Government is a friend of the fellah, the British nation takes account of the villager, honors him and perceives in him the most important factor in the prosperity of the country and in the increase of its means for producing wealtk. Zionism is the great school which the British Government has prepared for us, that the fellah may in it learn the art of agriculture and husbandry and the source of economic power. Ask them for the first (British mandate) and welcome the second (Zionism) with smiling faces, for they are the comerstone of your future prosperity and guides to that good path whereon you shall walk. And let those who threaten know that the men of the villages with all their lack of learning, are not so boorish as to allow the effendis to dominate their will and force them to listen to their words and follow them in their crooked path on which they wish to lead you too. To you, the Sheikhs and Mukhtars of the villages, I call. Beware, beware, do not sign any manifestos or resolutions which may be presented to you by interested parties. Know that such can only hinder you and your rights, and that their designs are known, while your past is the surest guarantee that the relations of friendship in the future will bring you to the road of tranquility and success. God’s blessing upon you. -