The Maccabaean
America was no more prepared than they, perhaps less. These very leaders, who have for the last few years here in New York played the part of great and important diplomats, have in London gone morally bankrupt. They neither knew how nor were they in a position to bring order into the chaos which reigned at the Convention.
Mr. J. Fishman in the Jewish Morning Journal is also disappointed with the American delegation. They gave the impression, he says, "of a man who had recently acquired wealth and was picking faults just to show that he knew everything because he has money."
The writer finds fault with the manner in which the American delegation represented the American Zionists.
The Zionist masses surely had not expected that the Americans would raise hair-splitting questions which paralyzed the whole machinery of the Conference. Had any American Zionist empowered the delegation to propose a sort of dictatorial government in Zionism? Had anybody heard, prior to the departure of the delegation, that the Palestine Commission must be abolished, that Palestine schools must be reduced to a ridiculous minimum, that Ussishkin must step out, that the Americans must leave the entire responsibility to the English Zionists and they would only criticise? And still it is a fact that this was put forth as the "American program." Is it any wonder that everybody was wondering what the Americans wanted?
Mr. Fishman, too, refers to the "invisible leadership" of Mr. Brandeis and his resorting to "ambassadors" in the persons of Frankfurter and DeHaas, who frequently disagreed with each other. The writer concludes by appealing to the American Zionists.
And what will happen now? Will the American Zionists finally take matters in their own hands? Will they approve the actions of the American delegation or will they tell the leaders in Europe that they will together with all Zionists work for their people? The next Convention will have to answer this question.
Mentor in the London Jewish Chronicle, in speaking of the American delegation, says: "There was, it seems, an insistent disposition shown by the American delegates to cut the painter; an irritating uneasiness at being a portion of a world-wide organization and a desire to be 'on their own.'"
He sees an attempt to establish a "Monroe Doctrine" for American Zionists and says: "But a Jewish Monroe Doctrine is an absurdity so gross, an idea so ridiculous, that Jove, who laughs at lovers' perjuries, would weep at the fickle falsity which could induce three millions of our brethren to shut the door of Jewry upon themselves and think that they could thus ensconce themselves in safety and security, moral or material, though the rest of the Jews of the world were to travel to Gehenna instead of to the Promised Land."
He continues:
We Jews are one and our fate is common to all. And so "Will they go?" has to be asked of American Jews. Not will they go off on their own and leave the Jewish National Movement to go hang, but will they go Palestinewards, if not in body, then in spirit? If they withdraw their hands from fear, or because of the call of material interests, or from pique, or selfishness, or lack of camaraderie, then forever a Cain-mark will be branded upon the brow of every one of them. By it all men shall know that at the very moment when our national prospects, if not too bright, at least were brighter than at any time this twenty centuries past, they suffered to be murdered by the material aspirations they have encouraged, the striving to be a free nation which is the gauge of the soul of any people.
Ninety-Two
The International Relief Conference
In speaking of the Carlsbad Relief Conference almost every newspaper comments upon the regretful absence of the Joint Distribution Committee. The Jewish Daily News is gratified that the Conference is being held "despite the fact that the Great Powers of the J. D. C. are having no share in it."
It is gratifying to know that our brethren over there, despite their great need of our help, have a sufficiency of independence and purposefulness to take action in accordance with the necessities of the Jewish situation which none know better than they do and not as certain proud American Jewish leaders would have them act, leaders who still cling to the belief that he who pays the piper, orders the tune.
The London Jewish Chronicle attempts to answer the apparent fears of the J. D. C. that such "a demonstration of international character might lead to misunderstanding." It says:
but if Jews are to be driven back to the impotence of isolated and sectional acting by this old bogey of "internationalism," they will surely injure their own vital interests without even placating their enemies, who would go on repeating their slanders if every Jew were sequestered from his brother the world over. The fact is, the very misery and sorrow which brought the Conference together were the best refutation of the current folly about a triumphant Jewish conspiracy. It was, indeed, a world conference, but that was only because our disasters are a world tragedy. As Advocate Sliosberg, the eloquent Russian Jew, exclaimed: "Come you all who believe that the Jews have some secret means by which they attempt to move the world! Those who lightly speak and believe such things, let them come here and see for themselves the crimes committed by the employment of race hatred and religious fanaticism, as tools of political class battle." It is the victims of those crimes, and not the leaders of a world conspiracy, who cry aloud for help. Fellow Jews at least will not pass them idly by.
The Toronto Hebrew Journal is of the opinion that the relief work both in the United States and in Canada must be reorganized before the Jews of North America would be able to carry through the decisions of the Conference.
The Philadelphia Jewish World also points to this difficulty, but finds that "the Conference may bring much that is useful if the delegates will but remember the limitations imposed upon them by the unfavorable conditions at present governing Eastern Europe. Let them make clear to the rest of Jewry just how great is the tragedy of Eastern Europe, let them convey it in all its details, so that it can be fully utilized at that moment in the future when it will be possible to go ahead with the work of reconstruction."
Sir Stuart Samuel's Report and the American Press
In the Gleanings and Echoes of last month we pointed to the difficulty which Sir Stuart's report on the Polish pogroms is meeting in seeking publication in the American press. Through the efforts of the American Jewish Congress The Nation printed a complete account of the vicissitudes of the report in the American press. It relates the story as follows:
The Samuel Commission was sent to Poland by the British Govern ment to investigate the treatment of Jews; its findings were withheld for months, as debates in the House of Commons revealed, and were finally made public on July 5. The Jewish-language newspapers of