The Maccabaean
Jews are called upon to speak at a Jewish meeting, they resert to compliments à la the Reverend Peter Madison. The tenor of the speeches which the non-Jews made at Albert Hall was totally different. They spoke not as if they had come to favor us with their presence, but as equals to equals.
The meeting was addressed by Balfour, Robert Cecil, Marquis Crewe, Ormsby-Gore and the labor leader, Wedgewood. All of them dealt with the Zionist problem in a profound manner. Balfour, the first speaker, is more than an ex-Minister. Balfour is a tower of strength in England. He is an English gentleman in the full meaning of the term. The title Lord gains significance by being associated with a man like Balfour. He is a scholar, a philosopher of the first rank. His opinions carry great weight in England. Balfour's opinions are shared by the upper classes of England, and partly by the present Government. His speech can, therefore, not be overestimated. He made no attempt to conceal the difficulties which Zionism will yet meet, and stressed the point that England, which had made a partnership with the Jewish people, would not desert it in its difficult task.
In the same vein spoke also Robert Cecil and Colonel Wedgewood. Cecil is a strong adherent of the League of Nations. In his opinion, the war produced two great ideals, the League of Nations and the opportunity to the Jewish people for restoring its homeland.
EEE VE» une Wedgewood approaches the same subject from a different point of view. He is not a nationalist, but he wants to see the Jews in their home because he believes that progress will therebv result. '
The Jewish speakers did not say anything new, but their manner was different. There was no trace of subordination, of flattery. They spoke as the equals of the representatives of the British Government. The Jewish people, as the second party, would also contribute to the partnership.
It was a historic meeting, the harbinger of a new era, which the Conference itself had not fully realized.
AMERICAN CONTRIBUTIONS
The American delegation came to the Conference with three ideas. The first was of a negative character, criticism. Tire other two were important productive ideas, which would have meant much for the future development of Zionism had they received the proper consideration on the part of the Conference. The reasons why they did not receive such consideration were many. The fault lay mostly in the conditions, but no less at fault were the persons who were by reason of the conditions put at the forefront of the movement, with the result that the entire activity of the American delegation consisted of criticism against extravagance in expenditures, which, important though it was, did not raise our prestige at the Conference.
First of all, the American delegation demanded a thorough housecleaning. They asked that the extravagance
which was natural in time of war and chaos, be now stopped. Secondly, and much more important, was the demand to transfer all the Zionist offices to Palestine, in accordance with the decision of our last Convention. This proposition included a critical review of the functions of the Commission, which was fundamentally right.
Thirdly, the Americans demanded that new forces be drawn into the movement, not mere names, but men who were especially qualified to solve the new problems in respect to the building of Palestine.
The demand that all Zionist activities be transferred to Palestine meant, of course, that the London offices be reduced to not more than a political office. Even the authority with regard to matters of organization should come direct from Jerusalem. This proposition should have received unanimous approval, but was quashed even before it saw the light, mainly because of the other proposition for drawing in new forces.
The latter met with strong opposition, and because of personal misunderstanding was almost put aside.
? Gun ” FEB VESBEEEIEEEE It is maintained that the plan was presented in an impossible form, and for this reason its content failed to gain proper appreciation. Possibly so. But if true, it is not at all complimentary to the Conference. It is also maintained that the plan came as a surprise even for the American delegation, which was not admitted into the “Inner Councils..” There is much truth in this contention, which is an old one and should be charged up to the old war conditions. At any rate, the plan did not receive the consideration it deserved.
. Still, it can be said that the American delegation did contribute something more than the suspicion it evoked.
> FE Its criticism had a wholesome effect. A clear understanding was reached with regard to the functions of the Commission and with regard to the relationship of London and Jerusalem insofar as the division of Zionist oflices was concerned. Most important was the decision to create an “economic council” of men experienced in industry and finance. This 'council will in time become an important factor in our constructive work in Palestine.
LONDON AND JERUSALEM
Jerusalem put the questions: Will they come? Will they build? London gave no direct answer to these questions, but still, taken as a whole, the Conference subconsciously attempted to answer them.
London, the Jewish London, sent to Jerusalem one of its best sons, Sir Herbert Samuel, who, from morning to night, every minute of the day, is thinking of the practical problem of building our land. He and the Asefash Hanivcharim (the Jewish Constituent Assembly) will help the Zionist Organization to find the new road which leads to the re-establishment of Palestine as the Jewish National Homeland and. Jerusalem as the new center of the flourishing Jewish land.
