The Anti-Jewish Atrocities in Poland
FULL TEXT OF ABOUT THE PAGE
Sir Stuart Samuel's Report on His Mission of Investigation
Last September a British Commission headed by Sir Stuart Samuel arrived in Warsaw to investigate the pogroms and other anti-Jewish outbreaks which were prevalent last year in Poland. Sir Stuart Samuel’s report has now been submitted to the British Parliament and the world at large. He unfolds his findings in a measured and dispassionate tone and his report bears particular contrast to that of Mr. Henry Morgenthau, who likewise investigated the Polish assaults against the Jews. Not that there is appreciable difference in the facts of each of these reports, but there is a wide divergence of emphasis. Mr. Morgenthau denoted the outbreaks as excesses and exonerated the Polish Government from responsibility for their occurrence. Sir Stuart Samuel does not hesitate to call the outbreaks “pogroms,” and takes care to define the word as an excess “organized by the Government against a portion of the population, or when the authorities took no steps to restrain those perpetrating the excesses or intervened at a period too late to be effective.” He speaks of the Pinsk outbreak as an “awful massacre” and “a military murder.” Again, Sir Stuart Samuel’s conclusion is not a neat moral urging the Jews to be good, but a set of recommendations that are specific and to a limited extent curative. TAccompanying Sir Stuart Samuel’s report is a covering letter of Sir Horace Rumbold,' British Minister to Poland (?) to Earl Curzon, which makes certain illuminating comments on the report—illuminating also upon the mental attitude of the British Consul. Sir Horace Rumbold notes that while the Polish authorities could not be held responsible for the excesses, the authors have not, so far as is known to the British Legation, been brought to book. He feels that the economic boycott ‘on the part of the Polish people against the Jews may be beyond the power of the Polish Government to remedy. He implies that the charge of pro-Germanism against the Jews has likely a sound foundation. He disagrees with Sir Stuart Samuel in regard to the part played by the Jews in the pre-war business and industrial activities of Poland; he states that only a small percentage of Polish manufactured goods were produced by the Jews and that Jewish initiative in Polish business matters is exaggerated. Finally, he calls particular attention to the fact that since Sir Stuart Samuel’s report deals only with the Jewish problem in Poland and omits consideration of the similar problem in the neighboring countries, a partial and consequently false picture is the result. “For... their condition in Poland, bad as it may have been or may still be, has been far better than in most of the surrounding countries.” He concludes by remarking that “it is giving the Jews very little real assistance to single out as is sometimes done, for reprobation and protest, the country where they have perhaps suffered least.” Following Sir Stuart Samuel’ report are the findings of Captain P. Wright, a member of the Samuel mission, and he presents what is in the nature of a minority and at the same time complementary report. Captain P. Wright feels that it is impossible to understand or estimate the Polish-Jewish antagonism without an adequate knowledge of the life and culture of the Jews in Poland today and their history in the Poland of a past. Captain Wright confesses his initial ignorance of these matters and then lays before the reader the result of his three months’ study. It is impossible to summarize the; perverse quality of Captain Wright’s description of Jewish life and manners. He is a man of literary skill and hides his dagger beneath an admirable cloak of words. A few quotations, however, may give the flavor of his mind: T“(Örthodox Jewish) religion and morality consist in the keeping of ritual and customary rules, and whatever rationalizing and reformed modern Jews may say, outside of these ritual and customary rules there is no religion or morality for the Orthodox.” “The Jews grew steadily in numbers because their standard of living was, and is, much lower than that of the Poles” T“When one thinks of what happened to the other racial, religious, and linguistic minorities of Europe in modern times, say, the French Protestants or the Irish Catholics, to take the first of numberless examples that come to hand, the Jew appears not as the most persecuted, but as the most favored, people of Europe.” “The Hebrew language before (the Nineteenth century) had been used for merely religious purposes, controversies on Torah and Talmud as to how many brazen lavers there were in Solomon’s Temple, or whether the fat in an animal’s tail is Kosher or not.” “If the upper half of the Eastern Jews is European, the lower half, the Chassidim, is not, and this lower half haunts the upper half, and: by the Poles the two halves are naturally identified,. West Jews do not drag this terrific tail after. them.” “When Orientals, in a mass... get European ideas, such as nationality, patriotism, social equality, liberty, and self-government, they begin to think they are a nation to whom their patriotism is due, and conversely that it is not due to the Europeans, from whom they obtained their ideas; that they are equal to these Europeans, and that being treated as an inferior caste is unjust. . . . So the very ideas benevolently sown by the Europeans spring up again in a hostile, armed, and formidable shape. During the last few years these feelings erystallized into the formation of ihe Nationalist or Zionist party... . The very ideas that Europeans disseminate to any oriental people may turn against them, and a partially Anglicized Beypt rises against the rulers its Oriental fathers welcomed. So it is with the Polish Jews.” T‘“ (The advance of the Poles in commercial fields) struck the Jews upon their sensitive nerve, their love of money aggravated by centuries of exclusive enjoyment, just as the Jewish Nationalist movement struck the Poles upon their sensitive nerve, national and racial pride, exasperated by a century of oppression. The Jew claims a right to all the profits, and the Pole to kick the Jew whenever he feels the inclination.” T[Considering the psychological condition which these samples display, Captain Wright’s conclusions with regard to the character ofthe outbreaks against the Jews and the fixation of responsibility are important and striking. He finds that “if anyone lays hands on a Jew, everyone else will willingly assist or connive.” “The responsibility for the excesses against the Jews falls most of all on the Polish intelligentsia, the educated, well-to-do class; then next, but less, on the masses. But last of all on the Government which, since the spring, has with earnest, though insufficient, exertions tried to stop the excesses.” T[ Captain Wright practically corroborates the facts of Sir Stuart Samuel’s findings; and the latter’s report follows in full.— THE EpITor. ' °
SIR
I was entrusted by His Majesty's Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs with a mission to Poland on behalf of His Majesty's Government, the primary object of which was to examine the specific charges that have been brought against the Poles of having ill-treated the Jewish population of their country, including any fresh cases of ill-treatment that might be brought to my notice whilst my mission lasted. I was, in particular, instructed to use my best endeavors to ascertain in each case where massacres or outrages of Jews had taken place, where and to what extent the different grades of Polish authorities were to blame either for encouraging or culpably failing to prevent them, or whether they had taken all steps in their power to suppress outbreaks and punish the offenders. The aim of my mission was to dissipate any misunderstandings that might have arisen and thus to promote mutual goodwill between Poland and Great Britain. I was therefore in-
structed to make such recommendations to His Majesty's Government as might occur to me with the object of establishing greater harmony between Jewish and other elements of the population, as a satisfactory solution of that problem would obviously go far to promote the national prosperity. The mission left London early in September and remained in Poland about three months. I took excesses against the Jewish population which occurred in Cracow, Lodz, Vilna, Lida, Pinsk, and Lemberg as typical, and visited those places from Warsaw. Traveling conditions in Poland at the period of the visits of the mission presented such difficulty, owing to heavy falls of snow and to the fact that a large number of passenger trains had ceased running in consequence of their accommodation being required for the transport of food, that the mission was unable to visit further towns.
My instructions directed my particular attention to the necessity of inquiring into the statements respecting occur-