The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXIV, No. 2 · August 1920
60printed page
scan 31 of 35

The Maccabaean

member at least in America or Canada. Experience has shown, as in the case of Ireland, that it is always a disadvantage to a country to.have an emigration of despairing people, as these sow the seed of their discontent in other lands. A further remedy for this congestion of occupation would be to introduce into Poland new industries, for which Jews in other countries have evinced special aptitude. The difficulty of securing raw material limits the occupations available at the present time, but it would appear quite feasible to start factories for the manufacture of waterproofing, galo- shes, furniture, boots, and clothing. Doubtless western Jews would be prepared to assist their brethren to reach a higher plane of industrial development, but unfortunately the Christian Poles, although not undertaking such enterprises to any extent themselves, exhibited distinct hostility to any such suggestion which would benefit both the Jews and the State alike. Many Poles, however, enlarge the demand for a reduction of the number of small Jewish tradesmen to one for the reduction of the Jewish population as a whole. This proposition is fraught with a danger not confined to the Jews; it is a’ danger to the State. To render the conditions of life so intolerable to the Jew as to force him to leave his native country, has ever been followed by disastrous consequences to the country, where this form of persecution has been essayed; whereas in every country, where the Jew has been granted an effective citizenship, he has provel himself a mainstay of law and order. The Jew has usually so much to lose through the consequences of disorder that he ranges himself instinctively on the side of good government. It is for the Poles to choose whether they will follow the example of Great Britain, the United States of America, France, Holland, Italy and the other liberal-minded States which have treated the Jew equitably, or link their fate with ancient Egypt, medisval Spain and modern Russia. It must further be considered that when the Jewis driven out, his capital is driven out with him. In fact, in most cases it precedes him, for the poor and helpless Jew is not the first to leave in face of economic persecution such as a boycott or the fear of personal safety, but rather he who possesses the means to seek happier conditions of livelihood elsewhere. Thus, at the very time when it is vital to the interest of Poland to import capital, were the suggested policy carried into action, it would have for its result the export of capital. In addition, there is the danger that the better minds amongst non-Jews would not be will- ine to remain in a country wherein truth and justice are absent.

Another policy appears to have as its object the identification of Jews as Bolsheviks in order to distract public attention from the Government. The real danger of Bolshevism, however, is to be sought in other directions, although it should not be matter for surprise if some of the younger generation of educated Jews, finding all avenues of advancement and fair play barred, should be found ready to listen to proposals for freedom and equality of opportunity. It is a fair retort that the Government policy is making potential revolutionaries of these people. If the Polish Government would grant the Jews a genuine, and not a masked, equality, they would secure the support of the most conservative law-abiding and loyal section of the population. All the Jews ask is to be allowed to live in peace and safety. By grinding them down by economic differentiation a certain number of these people may be induced to emigrate, but the danger will always remain that a certain residuum will be forced into the ranks of the disaffected and disloyal. The Jew may be robbed, plundered, have his beard cut and be otherwise insulted for a time, but who can be surprised if a point be reached when men will not tolerate such treatment longer and will be prepared to make the utmost sacrifices to achieve the honor of their manhood?

Under this hard and continued pressure many Jews have been constrained to change their religion, and it is mostly these "Jews" who are meant when "Jews" are mentioned as being in Government employ.

I made careful inquiries in various parts of Poland as to the extent to which Bolshevik principles had permeated the Jewish population, and the highest estimate which I encountered was 10 per cent. of their number, a considerably less proportion, according to my informants, than characterizes the population as a whole.

In investigating the truth of the statement that Jews in Poland sympathize with Bolshevism, attention must be paid to the fact that Jews form the middle class almost in its entirety. Above are the aristocracy and below are the peasants. Their relations with the peasants are not unsatisfactory. The young peasants cannot read the newspapers and are therefore but slightly contaminated by anti-Semitism until they enter the army. I was informed that it is not at all unusual for Polish peasants to avail themselves of the arbitrament of the Jewish rabbi's courts. Another point to be borne in mind is that a very considerable proportion of the Jews belong to the orthodox form of the religion. If I understand aright, Bolshevism stands against both religion and the bourgeoisie; it must therefore be clear from the above statements that by the acceptance of these tenets most of the Polish Jews would but compass their own destruction.

In conclusion, I desire to point out that, if the social boycott were successful in securing a large emigration of Jews, it would result in a very large decrease in the productive powers of Poland. As the future of the republic depends largely upon its exports exceeding its imports the future of the State itself might be imperilled. The Polish Government would be well advised in its own interests that to take immediate and active measures to bring this unsatisfactory condition of affairs to a speedy end, would be acting in the best interests of the people committed to its charge.

I now propose to report upon the result of my investigations into the excesses perpetrated in the towns I visited in the order they occurred. Before doing so I would like to remark that as statements that the Jews were enemies of the rest of the population, and that all misfortunes were to be ascribed to their influence, were constantly circulated, and the Jews formed an easy prey for robbery and plunder, attacks upon them were to be expected. It was, however, the evil example of the military as they entered captured towns which as a rule incited the civil population to join in the programs. If the military commanders had but performed their duty to humanity and their office, the loss of life would have been considerably less. Poland, too, would not be burdened with these still unpunished crimes.

Lemberg. —With regard to the events in Lemberg on the 21st, 22d and 23d November, 1918, consideration has to be given to the very remarkable position that was to be found in that city at the period, and it is noteworthy upon what a small scale were the operations. Previous to the date mentioned the Ukrainian army consisted of about 10,000 men in occupation of that portion of East Galicia, but General Monczynski raised a Polish army, about 1,500 in number, consisting of men, women, boys, some of them criminals, and after a severe struggle, succeeded in capturing half the city, the other half of which remained in the occupation of the Ukrainians, The Jewish part of the population of Lemberg declared itself to be neutral. After street fighting of a severe character the Polish forces succeeded in driving the Ukrainians entirely out of the city. This result was achieved through the advent of a considerable body of Polish troops brought under General Roja from Posen. It has been proved to my satisfaction that these troops were promised three days’ free looting of the Jewish quarter, and I had it in evidence that Jews were warned by Christian friends of the certainty of a pogrom on the days mentioned. The Polish soldiers and population were somewhat incensed by the attitude of the Jews in not having assisted them in their struggle, but nothing can excuse the work of robbery and murder which took place on the days mentioned (21st, 22d and 23d November).