The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXIV, No. 2 · August 1920
56printed page
scan 27 of 35

The Maccabaean

moving on our poor people, for shifting the shiftless, and at most turning the land of our people’s two thousand years’ hope into a convalescent home for the disabled of our brethren. The anti-Zionist utilized your Declaration, so that he might scoff at the Nationalist aspirations of Jews in whom the fine old spirit of love for Zion and devotion to Israel still resided. In your words, he saw finis put to Zionist strivings, and Palestine, long rocking in the uncertainty of Turkish ruin, now definitely set as a British Possession. So I might go on telling you how the various shades and nuances of those interested, Jews or non-Jews, in the future of Palestine and the relation of our people to it, came to see reflected upon themselves the words you wrote to Lord Rothschild. Mentor concluded with this direct question, ‘A Jewish National Home,’ meaning by that, the building up of a Jewish Commonwealth as Jewish as England is English, or as Canada is Canadian—that and that alone is the way out. Do you mean that? Is that the interpretation of your Declaration, or was your Declaration but a dream?”

Mr. Balfour, while again using in his speech the term "Jewish National Home," did not "in any way translate or elucidate the meaning of his phrase," thinks the Jewish Chronicle.

"But he did, particularly in the concluding words of his speech, declare that Palestine is to be made a home for the Jewish People, 'in the fullest measure and degree.' To be sure, the essential value of that determination depends upon the exact interpretation that is to be set upon the expression Jewish National Home, an expression which, as it stands, is, it must be admitted, elusive, and therefore may be evasive. But Dr. Weizmann has, as we pointed out last week, pledged his word as leader of the Zionist Movement that 'no external obstacle now prevents us (Jews) from settling down to the work of reconstruction of the Jewish National Home.... The Government has set up all the necessary political conditions for making the Jewish National Home. They regard us as being free henceforth to make of Palestine as Jewish a country as we are capable. The task is ours and nobody else's.' While these words are capable of being twisted into devious meanings, to the plain man they have a plain meaning, just as Mr. Balfour's words have a plain meaning. And the plain meaning is the one which the meeting understood, and which, it is only reasonable to suppose, the speakers intended it should understand. It is that the policy of the future of Palestine is to be the creation there, in due time, of a Jewish Commonwealth, so that ultimately Palestine may become—and we repeat a formula which we know is more than familiar to our readers—as Jewish as England is English, or as Canada is Canadian."

Neither is Mr. Zangwill satisfied. He wishes to have a "charter of rights," an assurance that the National Home will be established even in face of 600,000 Arabs.

"If not," he says, "I personally must refuse, especially amid the greatest volume of suffering that even the Galuth has ever known, to spend either money or energy upon the New British possession without better guarantees for its Jewish future than the Zionist leaders have yet provided. It was unfortunate that Lord Robert Cecil should say the two outstanding outcomes of the war would be the 'Jewish National Home,' and the League of Nations. If the first is to be as great a farce as the second, heaven help the Jewish State!"

Palestine Discussed in British Parliament

British civil administration in Palestine actually begining with the arrival of Sir Herbert Samuel, the question of British policy in Palestine, especially the interpretation of "a national home for the Jewish people" is undergoing serious discussion. In the House of Lords, Earl Curzon, the Minister for Foreign Affairs, was called upon to explain "by what means it was proposed to safeguard the rights of

Fifty-Six

the immense non-Jewish majority of the population while setting up a 'national home' for the Jewish race." The lengthy answer of Lord Curzon is unsatisfactory to the Jewish Chronicle, especially the point he made with reference to emigration, that "our general policy is that no man or woman shall be admitted whom the country is incapable of supporting, and that indiscriminate mass immigration whether of Jews or non-Jews, whether of Jews from Russia or other parts of the world, will most certainly not be permitted."

The Jewish Daily News is delighted with Lord Curzon's expression that "Jews and Jews alone can develop Palestine," and thinks that this new declaration strengthens and fortifies Balfour's original declaration.

The Day, while not particularly relishing Lord Curzon's statement finds consolation in Dr. Weizmann's opinion that the episode in the House of Lords did not in the slightest change the position of Palestine, and says further:

"We assume that this is so, and even if this or that particular expression on the part of Lord Curzon does not appeal to our Jewish susceptibilities, his statement to the English government will live up to its promise of creating a Jewish Home in Palestine despite all obstacles, is sufficient. If, until now, we were not very clear as to what was actually promised us, it is to be hoped that that will be made clear at the forthcoming Conference."

The London Daily Telegraph takes the view of Lord Curzon with regard to emigration:

"Indeed, we can imagine nothing less desirable for Palestine than a flood of the poorest class of Jewish refugees from Poland, Galicia, or Roumania, unless, indeed, it were a trickle of educated Jewish and Bolshevik propagandists from Russia. The future of Palestine depends mainly upon the character of the Jewish immigrants who will enter the country, and though Sir Herbert Samuel's liberal sympathies would naturally incline him to the policy of the open door, we have the fullest confidence that a most careful scrutiny will be taken of all who present themselves for admittance."

A correspondent in the London Spectator looks askance at the future inhabitants of Palestine and finding that the chief source of Jewish immigration must of necessity be Central Europe or Russia, he says:

"It is, to say the least of it, doubtful whether such immigrants will be a desirable acquisition for Palestine; and it requires little imagination to realize what opportunities such immigration will afford the Bolshevists (whose avowed design is the overthrow of the British Empire) for introducing into Palestine, and through Palestine to other portions of Asia and Africa, their pernicious agents and propaganda."

The editor of the Spectator sharing the view of his correspondent that

"at the present time the majority of Palestinians would prefer Arab rule, or even a reversion to Turkish misrule, to a British mandate coupled with preferential rights for Jews. The appointment of a Jewish High Commissioner leaves them aghast; and Arab propagandists, who assert openly that the British Government has been bought by Jews, find ready credence."

is quick to point out the moral:

"It shows how great a blunder was committed by the appointment of Sir Herbert Samuel. Its effect was to put a Zionist interpretation upon Mr. Balfour's 'National Home for the Jews.' We do not believe Mr. Balfour meant pure and unadulterated Zionism, but after the selection of a Hebrew Zionist to rule in Palestine it will be almost impossible to get the Jews to take any other view."