The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXIV, No. 2 · August 1920
55printed page
scan 26 of 35

The Maccabaean

The Day does profess to understand Justice Brandeis, but finds reason to disagree with him.

"We can understand the motives which prompt Mr. Brandeis, who is after all a convinced democrat to insist upon a plan which must be identified as autocratic. The rebuilding of Palestine is a most difficult matter, one demanding the greatest tact, enormous perseverance and a practical conception. The fewer concerned in the matter of final decisions the better and the safer for the great work in hand.

"But this theory of the practical has already been sufficiently tested and found wanting. All autocratic governments prided themselves upon this theory and all supporters of the 'powerful hand' sung its praises. The practical accomplishments of an unlimited control concentrated in the hands of a few is almost always attained at the expense of the people's grave interests, quite apart from the fact that it tends to paralyze various very necessary forces."

The Jewish Morning Journal is also dissatisfied with the plan of Justice Brandeis and thinks that all elements ought to get proper representation. It says:

"The reorganization will be of value only then when in the ranks of the executive will be found representatives of the great mass of Palestine orthodox Jewry, the Mizrachi, representatives of the radical elements and what is even more important, representatives of Jewry generally, which feels sympathetically towards Zionism and is ready to help in the realization of the British promise through the Balfour Declaration, with money, brains and labor. To bring the undertaking to a successful issue, the co-operation of orthodoxy and finance are essential, and any leader who fails to appreciate this fact, is altogether in the wrong place."

Opposition to the men who became the emergency leaders of the Zionist Organization and criticism of the Zionist Commission manifested themselves at the very opening of the Conference. Dr. Max Nordau became the leader of the "opposition." The Jewish press is divided in its attitude toward the opposition. The Day thinks that it is "healthy criticism" and says:

"Quite irrespective of the respect and confidence which we may possess towards those who helped in such great measure to realize the Zionist ideal, we must admit, that working continuously on one's own responsibility, errors are unavoidable.

"The report of Dr. Chaim Weizmann, who was at the head of the Zionist Commission in Palestine since the Balfour Declaration, called forth considerable criticism from various directions. Admitting that Dr. Weizmann and colleagues encountered great difficulties, it is still made clear from the criticisms that the Commission was bureaucratic in its methods paying but slight heed to the Palestine Jewish population and its demands."

The Jewish Morning Journal agrees with the point in Dr. Weizmann's defense of the work of the Commission that the latter was handicapped by reason that the Jews of Palestine are divided into too many parties, and are too intent on politics. "This touches a weakness for which there is no remedy," it thinks.

"What can the best administration accomplish in the face of a people that is all split up and ready to destroy anything and everything which it does not approve or cherish, and which indulges in fault-finding, believing it to be a sort of pastime and finding pleasure in embarrassing its leaders. The tendency on the part of our brethren to revolt at every possible opportunity quite as often emanates from a lack of sincerity as from any sense of over-sincerity."

"Both healthy and justified" thinks the Jewish Daily Eagle of Montreal, of the opposition, while the Jewish World of Cleveland sides with Weizmann as against Nordau. The Jewish World of Philadelphia particularly resents

the criticism of Rabbi Fishman of the Mizrachi and takes occasion to rap the Mizrachi program as a whole.

"The criticism of the right wing of the opposition—the 'Mizrachi'—is peculiar in its evident forgetfulness that we are now living in the twentieth century and not in the thirteenth. The 'Mizrachiists' complain at the fact that the Administration in Palestine established by the Zionist Commission is not conducted in the Jewish spirit of the 'Mizrachi.' Ignoring the fact that the Mizrachi is such a small portion of the Zionist Organization we say that it is an absurdity that sensible people should earnestly believe that a State can now be built on principles laid down by a conservative religious sect."

Continuing further its argument against the Mizrachi it agrees with Weizmann, who said that the Mizrachi must once and for all give up the idea that they have a monopoly on Judaism and that the sooner they do so the better it will be for the Jews of Palestine and the welfare of the new Jewish Homeland.

The Conference closed with an apparent victory for the Administration. Weizmann and Sokolow retained the leadership and they were strengthened by the selection of Justice Brandeis as Honorary President. The disappointment of the opposition is evidenced by the resignation of Dr. Nordau, Prof. Marmoreck, and Jean Fischer from the Greater Actions Committee. These men are all veterans in the Zionist movement, the Zionist "Old Guard" as The Day calls them. This paper, too, does not regret their resignation. It says:

"While it is perhaps regrettable that the party should lose as active workers such personalities as Nordau, Marmoreck, and Fischer, it is, nevertheless, better for the party and for the cause for which the party exists, that the leadership should be turned over to new men who are not bound to traditions—new times—new people."

The Zionist Demonstration

In connection with the Conference, the English Zionist Federation arranged a Zionist Demonstration at Albert Hall. The distinguished speakers, the ten thousand people who packed the hall, and the thousands who were turned away for lack of room, and the circumstances of the meeting made the demonstration, according to the Jewish Chronicle, "a remarkable occasion and a great attainment."

The speech of Mr. Balfour was awaited with great interest. It was hoped he would define the exact meaning of his "Declaration." He was earnestly beseeched by Mentor in the Jewish Chronicle to do so.

"Your Declaration was a masterpiece of unclarity. It attained that eminence, paradoxically enough, by reason of its crystal clearness. Do you happen to have come across a wonderful little fable—speaking from memory it is Scandinavian in origin—which tells of a remarkably translucent stream that had the capacity of reflecting to those who gazed into it, precisely what they were, not in outward form but in their inward spirit? Thus the vain one, albeit he pretended to modesty, looked into it and beheld a peacock; the stupid one, though assuming airs of wisdom, saw in reflection an ass, the really mean man the form of a sordid miser, and so on through a whole category of translation. It was the wonderful clarity of the stream which performed this marvel. So was it with your Declaration. Each man saw in it the reflection of his Jewish soul. The ardent Nationalist perceived it as the manumission at last of his people, the opening wide of the gates of his political freedom so that he might enter into his rightful heritage, so that Jews ceasing to be a hyphenation might become a nation. The Jew with shrivelled soul, on the other hand, cramped and wizened by his craven idolatry to the mere material in life, also read your Declaration with joy. For to him it meant nothing that would disturb his equanimity by applying the acid test to his Judaism, but just another plan for the