The Maccabaean
The specifications of this graceful pulpit-pamphlet are: forty-four pages of delicate writing; familiar-essay style making the sermon material ingratiating; some solid ideas, of importance to every Jewish nationalist, neatly packed; the religious Jewish point of view of Zionism presented without bookish theology and without bandying the word Zion about; a stimulus to Jewish national pride achieved throush the most efleacrious blend of loric and noetic allusions.
Rabbi David B. Suiren probably did not set out to achieve all this when he modestly began to differentiate “Jew” “Hebrew” and “Israel.” But, fortunately he possesses an invigorating style, a mastery of both the “p’shat” and the “d’rash” elements of Jewish learning and lore, and a finely attuned sense of balance. So that he has created—not an “educational,” heavy-footed, didactic book, but a poetically insinuating little essay, which wise Zionists may use in more ways than one as excellent Zionist propaganda. A substantial book of Rabbi David Suiren’s charming homiletics is something to look forward to with pleasure.
"Plays for a People's Theatre"
"Plays for a People's Theatre." Volume I, "The Fight for Freedom." By DOUGLAS GOLDING. 12mo. Published by Thomas Seltzer.
Is there a doctor in the theatre? If so, will he kindly step up? Our author is suffering from a bad attack of sentimentalized ideas, complicated by a swelling-up, symphonizing the Lack of the Sense of Humor. And his pomposity is bloated, and his intentions are so serious he doesn't know how to use them. Oh. dear!
Lately a number of really earnest people, and men of brilliant achievement in other fields, have begun to look on the theatre as a vacant lot, on which to dump ideas. By getting the “proletariat” on to the lot with (the mixed-up metaphor was created by themselves) an Aladdin’s lamp, a wondrous.structure, a tower of social righteousness, a citadel of human kindliness is to be erected over night. All this can come about irrespective of what dramatic rubbish is dumped on the “lot,” just so the right author gives the lamp the correctiy revolutionary rub.
Now, once and for all, this is our dogma, and we are hopelessly middle-class in it: You cannot make a power of the “theatre for the people” with the proper dramatic foundations. People go to the theatre to see human character, to watch a story told and acted and to be thrilled by beauty, by suffering or by joy of real, living human beings. Roughly speaking, that's what we understand to be the leritimate functions of art.
But net all the honest convictions or righteous truths or profound thoughts in the world will, of their own validity, affect an audience in any way. In the theatre everybody, especially “the people,” says to the author: “If you can’t convince me of your characters, how do you expect me to believe your ideas?”
Now Douglas Golding, feeling very keenly about his ideas of the New Dawn, and seeing the apparently vacant “lot,” has come up with his own cast of speeches and said, “Come, let us fashion a People’s Theatre. I generously contribute, as the Aladdin’s lamp, my own first play.”
We believe in all of Golding’s social theories, more’s the pity, ut not through reading them in this play. ‘The Fight for Freedom” du never be as much as a slat in the structure of the People’s Theatre. He has made the fatal error of being as slushy-sentimental about his own ideas as a Broadway playwright is about the “heroine” —-and of the two a slushy heroine is at least human. He has thrown together a fair plot—if only he knew that his plot revolved around people instead of mouthpieces. But essentially ihis play is merely an idea, dressed up for the stage, and not knowing if it is coming on or going ofl.
If “The Peopie’s Theatre” is to be like this we shall make a bargain; we shall submit to every course in social theories and promise to believe and act on every idea—provided we are excused from : being bored in the theatre by the same stuff. And we want to be clearly understood—we say bored only. We want to be convinced of ideas in the theatre as with Galsworthy’s “Justice.” Emotionally presented, ideas belong in the theatre. But we refuse to submit to ennui in anything, even for the sake of the “New Dawn.” We’d rather have the vacant lot than splinters of thoughts.
There is a peculiarly fine air of self-satisfaction in the preface of "The Fight for Freedom," throughout the telling of the People's Theatre and what kind of plays should go into it. It is quite taken for granted that this play will rank among the very greatest. The author is elated with enthusiasm over his own play. Oh, is there a doctor, to offer a corrective sense of humor?
Let us conclude our prayers, ladies and gentlemen, by an excerpt from the preface of the published play—“the people to control such a theatre must, it seems to me, be people accustomed to do jobs of work connected with the stage (our italics), and their first task must be, politely but firmly, to push the god-dam-art (his profanity) crowd outside.”
Come on outside!
Gilbert Murray on the Great War
Our Great War and the Great War of the Ancient Greeks. By GILBERT MURRAY. Published by Thomas Seltzer.
It appears that when our scholars and philosophers set out to reach the average man by intellectual entertainment they succeed far better than when our literary men attempt to make men think by the most hardy theatrical forms.
Thomas Seltzer, publisher of “Plays for a People’s Theatre,” is also the publisher of Gilbert Murray’s book, and this latter is an exquisite performance. It is a book in which a parallel of our own great war is reconstructed from the Greek classics with such fine humor as to disarm the lowliest of “low-brows.” It is a book with many reflections on much learning, compressed into delicately apnealing English for the averare man.
It is worth re-reading many times, once each for its precious style, for its compact architecture, for its wise telescoping of history, and for its quality of pithy human-ness.
The World and the Little Nations
(Continued from page 12)
membership of the League can be confined to reasonable numbers and the problems that confront it to manageable proportions.
One other point may be suggested for consideration. National revivals often express themselves in a zeal for the national languages. Irish, Welsh, Czech, Polish, Hebrew, are the objects of much devotion on the part of their adherents. One may sympathize wholly with the movement, and yet realize that it may be carried to excess. The little peoples may find themselves intellectually isolated through their very enthusiasm for their own tongues, and reduced to inefliciency in consequence. Whatever message they may have for mankind may be lost through inability to make it heard.
The danger, indeed, is obvious and is usually foreseen. Although it may be long before it will be generally recognized that a small people ought to seek, where the conditions allow, a dual political status —a certain measure of independence combined with a certain measure of federalism— it is already generally recognized that in a country speaking one of the minor languages, the population should, as far as possible, be bi-lingual. The best friends of the principle of nationality will be those who, while advocating the revival and cultivation among the smaller peoples of their distinctive languages, will urge the acquisition of one of the world-languages as well.
Such measures among others may help to maintain, in these critical, formative days, the right balance between separateness and communication, on the importance of which George Eliot, through the mouth of one of her characters, was wise to insist.
