The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXIV, No. 1 · July 1920
26printed page
scan 25 of 28

The Maccabaean

More mad than the fierce tiger?For this is what the tiger needs:To kill his neighbors all about.And yet he kills not half so wellAs Man, who needs his neighbor man to live.

To the tiger solitude and strength,And to the bird a nest,And to the bee a hive,And to the moose a herd,And to the savage man a tribe,And to the man of God the earth,This whole round earth, to conquer it.

Bitterness and despair may inspire poets no less than joy and gladness and it is only the saccharine and mealy mouthed who will not be able to understand that poetry may be made out of the ingredients of pain. H. S.

A Guide to Zionism

A Guide to Zionism. Edited by JESSIE E. SAMPTER. Published by the Zionist Organization of America.

The demand for a thorough, yet popularly written, book on Zionism, has been met in the publication of this volume. This "Guide" has been worth waiting for; it will take first place in Zionist propaganda literature, even when we have much more literature in English on the many phases of Zionism than we now possess.

Here is a book like a well ordered house—practical, attractive in every corner and with each part surprisingly accessible. The casual reader, or the hurried reader, need not read from cover to cover to find the ready answer for any of the scores of questions in Zionist history, theory or achievement. The arrangement of material in this respect is remarkably handy and always at the finger-tips.

And yet there is new material for the most intensive student; apparently obscure corners of Zionist thought are connected with the main corridors of the structure, so that no matter where the reader starts in the book he will immediately see the relation to the whole design, and be fascinated into exploring further into the many divisions of the narrative, and the forward-viewed problems of Zionism. In short, this is the long wished for book in which the reader can go journeying for pleasure or for information—over shortcuts and on small excursions, or for long sustained intellectual travel.

"The Guide to Zionism" edited by Miss Sampter, contains thirty-three chapters, connected serially, yet independently readable. It begins with the earliest dawn of Jewish national consciousness, and brings the subject down to happenings as recent as last year—touching on every phase of Zionism, and illuminating each shade of Zionist belief, every tendency and development sympathetically, but with proper non-partisanship. There are answers to all the leading arguments advanced against Zionism.

References to articles and books in English placed after each chapter, and a general list of available volumes included at the end of the book, open avenues of larger information on many particular subjects. There are special directions for study-circles; and appendices containing invaluable Zionist chronological tables, statistics of all the material relating to Jewish colonies in Palestine, maps, a well-compiled index and artistic illustrations of Zionist notables and of landmarks, of new and old Palestine.

The volume is got up to please the eye as well. It is tastefully printed and well bound.

An East Side Autobiography

Rebels: Into Anarchy—and Out Again. By MARIE GANZ, in collaboration with NAT J. FERBER. Dodd, Mead & Company, New York.

If Marie Ganz, as an autobiographer, had been permitted to go her own unsophisticated way, instead of having had a trained collaborator imposed upon her, we might have had a clear knowledge of her. It is among the prime purposes of an autobiography to give a full-length portrait of the writer. The collaboration has conspired

against definiteness. To the objection that Marie Ganz did not know how to write and therefore needed a trained collaborator, the reviewer answers that neither did Elizabeth Hasanovitz know how to write and nevertheless told a tale in "One of Them" worth the telling.

It is, after all, Marie Ganz in whom our interest centers. Those pictures and tales of the East Side which are worked into the story, sometimes without regard to their fitness and included with the intention of feeding our literary slummers on the pap to which they have been accustomed, militate against the value of the autobiography. Those irrevelancies referred to are caricatures rather than pictures. The over-emphases are too glaringly evident. Whoever did them or whoever the person upon whose suggestion or instruction they were included, seemed more concerned about sustaining the conception of the East Side held outside the East Side than in painting an honest picture of that part of the city. The writers should have used their opportunity to shatter those misconceptions rather than to sustain them.

For the truth is that the East Side no longer is and for a long time has not been that quagmire of misery it is here represented. Miss Ganz makes it evident that although her own hunger moved her to rebellion, it was the knowledge that the tyranny represented by her hunger was a thousandfold emphasized by the tyranny against the Colorado miners that first made her raise her voice in bitter protest. She was truly a rebel, and though the press, police and public outside the Ghetto regarded her as an anarchist, -her rebellion was not classifiable. She was the rebel moved by the denials to which she was obliged to submit rather than the rebel born out of intellectual travail. The immediate cause of rebellion removed, she joined the conservatives, in whose camp she has found comfort and leisure and the opportunity to write or half-write the story of her early vicissitudes. Those vicissitudes were powerful enough to down a stronger person, but the impulse of protest saved her. She found in those circumstances the opportunity for attaining her full spiritual growth, although the process of attainment involved notoriety, public contumely, police suspicion, arrest and imprisonment. And now, as if in mockine contempvlation of herself. she writes:-

"Radicalism is just as certain to be bred by poverty as conservatism is by wealth. The rich man's ideas and the poor man's are never going to agree. All of which reminds me that Ichael Schwartz once won a bet on a one-hundred-to-one chance in the Honduras lottery and, immediately undergoing a complete change in his political opinions, became an eloquent defender of the rights of capital against the foes of law and order. He lost his winnings in another gamble a few days later and was metamorphosed into a noisy agitator against prevailing social conditions."

It was during the Colorado miners' strike when she made a rather pathetic attempt on the life of John D. Rockefeller that she reached the peak of her notoriety, suffering injuries inflicted by a mob, arrest and imprisonment. Then followed a period of rest and study, during which she gradually disassociated herself from the propaganda. Then the war, which she accepted as just and necessary (though it would hardly have mattered had her decision been the contrary) and then she knew that she was an American.

"And of a sudden, the spirit of national pride awoke in me. The flag bore a new meaning. Oh, America, mighty and just, rallying to save the world! I was proud that I, I too, was an American. It was my flag, my cause. And I cried out to myself: 'Good-bye, past! Good-bye, old mates! Good-bye, old doubts! Good-bye, old comrades of a cause that is dead! My country is calling and I know the road that is right!'" H. S.

Enjoyable Homiletic Propaganda

What's in Our Names? By Rabbi DAVID B. SUIREN. The Star Publishing Co., Wilmington, Delaware.

Once in a while the pulpiteer steps down to the level of his fellow-men to fashion an example of the lost art of homiletics, and proves it can be done with a thrill of enjoyment for the lay reader. “What’s in Our Name?” a quaint blend of Jewish Rabbinic scholarship, stout nationalist sentiment and picturesque essay writing, has turned the trick—we hope it is the Airst of a series.