The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXIV, No. 1 · July 1920
21printed page
scan 20 of 28

Gleanings and Echoes of the Press

Samuel's Appointment

THE appointment of Sir Herbert Samuel to the post of High Commissioner for Palestine found whole-hearted endorsement in the Jewish and non-Jewish press alike, with few exceptions. Among those exceptions the anti-Jewish London Morning Post, of course, takes the lead. The Morning Post objects to the entire British policy in Palestine. It objects still more strenuously to the appointment of Sir Herbert Samuel because "as a Jew he cannot rule in Palestine." In a long editorial headed "Sir Herbert Samuel's Mistake," the Morning Post rails against the appointment, and while urging that it "makes no personal reflection upon Sir Herbert," it objects to a Jewish administrator because "the Arabian population do not and cannot regard Sir Herbert Samuel in any other aspect than the racial aspect; and we need not dwell upon consequence." It concludes with the rhetorical question "is there no Englishman competent to discharge the duties of High Commissioner in Palestine?". The London Daily Express supports the Morning Post and says "we ought to cancel, even at the eleventh hour, the despatch of Sir Herbert Samuel as High Commissioner of Palestine and to revoke all interest in the tribal rivalries over Arabia."

Needless to say, Sir Herbert’s appointment caused great rejoicing in Zionist and general Jewish circles. Contrary to the fears that the initial period of Palestine administration in the hands of a Jewish Governor would prejudice Jewish interests, Dos Yiddishe Folk feels that “the situation created in Palestine by Arabian politics and the attitude of the military administration leave no doubt that now is not the time for a policy of ‘pussyfooting;’ that the one logical and effective method to establish peace and stability in Palestine would be to allow Jewish aspirations to manifest themselves at every possible occasion.. The more clearly it is shown to the Arabians that England is thoroughly bent upon its decision to make Palestine the national Jewish Homeland, the faster will Pan-Arabian intrigues disappear and the faster will the inhabitants accept the new condition created by the Balfour Declaration. For that purpose, therefore, the appointment of a Jewish High Commissioner, and especially of one who is as Zionistic as Sir Herbert Samuel, is highly desirable”

The American Yiddish Press and’the Anglo-Jewish Press hail the appointment as of almost equal importance with the San Remo decision. “It proves beyond all further doubt that England is in perfect good faith and absolutely honest in her Jewish policy in Palestine,” says the New York Day.

The send-off dinner tendered by the Zionist Organization to Sir Herbert Samuel on Tuesday, June 15th, provided occasion for the writing of numerous congratulatory articles in the British Press. The London Times thinks that the Farewell Dinner “was an occasion of international and indeed of world-wide significance.” It continues to say this with regard to Sir Herbert’s appointment:

"We can well understand that Sir Herbert Samuel should have regarded the position offered him as a privilege rather than a sacrifice. To the lot of few Jews has it fallen to be given an opening so fraught with possibilities of good for their race—or so hedged about with dangers. In accepting

it, he has shown courage; in using it he will, we believe, show wisdom. He will carry with him to Palestine the good will of all who understand the high importance of stating the Jewish question in its true terms, and of enabling Jews, to stand on an assured footing among the great peoples nf +ha aarth ”

The London Daily Telegraph agrees with the Times that “Sir Herbert Samuel has no easy task,” but, it continues to say, “he goes to it with. trained capacity. A strong, but never a violent politician, he won his way to the Cabinet and in oflice; his opponents will readily admit, he was a conspicuously successful administrator, firm, adroit and sagacious. The Westminster Gazette and the Edinburgh Scotsman comment favorably upon Mr. Samuel’s statement that “complete religious liberty will be maintained in Palestine; the places sacred to the great religions will’remain in the control of all the adherents to those religions,” although the Morning Post thinks that anything Mr. Samuel has said or might say would not affect favorably “the people not of his own kind” in Palestine because “they are immovably preiudiced in advance.”

The Farewell Banquet to Mr. Samuel is considered by the London Jewish Chroniele as a “grand and inspiring occasion” and that few of those present at the banquet “will fail to retain the inspiration until the last days of their life.” The Jewish Chronicle sees this opportunity to contrast Mr. Samuel’s broadminded, sane, Jewish idealism to the “feeling super-Britishry of a short-sighted few.” Addressing itself to the “short-sighted few” it says, “and the apathetic —or the anemic—in spirit, who have shunned both their Jewish associations and their Jewish duties have a rebuke offered them and they would be debased indeed not to feel it in their very bones.”

"The Jewish Peril"

Perhaps it is more than a coincidence that at this very time when Jewish aspirations for a National Homeland in Palestine are being realized, when, as the first High Commissioner of Palestine is appointed, Herbert Samuel, the Jew and Zionist, and despite the continued outrages against Jews in Eastern Europe, the Jewish problem seems well on the way to solution, there again crops up the ugly head of anti-Semitism. One has almost grown accustomed to anti-Semitism in Germany and continual Jew-baiting in Austria, but that England, which is the Mandatory of the Jewish Homeland, and America, which has given a home to three million Jews, should so readily import a “made in Germany” article—the former through the “Rolls-Royce” columns of certain “respectable” newspapers, and the latter through the “Ford” columns of the Dearborn Independens —is indeed a cause for grief.

Solemnly the world is being warned in an anonymous pamphlet called the "Jewish Peril" of a huge Jewish conspiracy to overthrow and to capture the present government. The pamphlet appeared in London and in Berlin. It contains "documents" in the form of "Protocols of the Learned Elders of Zion," designed to prove that the Jews in conspiracy with certain secret brotherhoods are at the bottom of all political and religious convulsions and all the