The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXIV, No. 1 · July 1920
14printed page
scan 13 of 28

The Maccabaean

ter, after all, of mere words? To be granted this stipulation at San Remo while in Jerusalem a set of unsympathetic or obtuse military officials were laying a dead hand on every effort towards the development of the land and doing nothing to discourage the enemies of the Jewish hope, was after all a doubtful consolation. Naturally, therefore, the cry arose that the Palestine administration must be changed, that a civil government must be instituted which will understand and act in accord with the terms under which the Palestine mandate has been assigned to Great Britain. And it became clear to all that the kind of appointment which would be made of the head of the new government would either dispel or strengthen the suspicions which had been uttered against the sincerity of the British Government after the program in Jerusalem.

The appointment of Sir Herbert as the head not only dispels all suspicion as to the present sincerity of the British Government, but proves conclusively that this Government has always been sincere in the matter. It was early in the present year that Sir Herbert visited Palestine and studied its conditions at the behest of the Government. It was doubtless the Government's intention even then that Sir Herbert should become the head of the Civil Government of Palestine when the time for establishing it arrived.

Why does Sir Herbert’s appointment dispel all suspieion? Simply because Sir Herbert is a Zionist. He has familiarized himself thoroughly with the Zionist philosophy and aspirations as well as with the Zionist difhiculties. In his various interviews and statements he has not hesitated, while always giving assurances as to the rights and liberties of all peoples in Palestine, to emphasize the purpose to create in that land the national Jewish home. It is appropriate in this connection to reproduce his latest and most comprehensive oflicial statement which is dated London, June 13:

"Complete religious liberty will be maintained in Palestine. Places sacred to the great religions will remain in control of the adherents of these religions. Civilian administration for the country will be established immediately. The higher ranks will consist of British officials of ability and experience. The other ranks will be open to the local population, irrespective of creed. Order will be enforced firmly. The economic development of the country will be promoted actively.

"In accordance with the decision of the Allied and Associated Powers, measures will be adopted to reconstruct the Jewish National Home in Palestine. The yearnings of the Jewish people for 2000 years, of which the modern Zionist movement is the latest expression, will at last be realized. Steps taken to this end will be consistent with scrupulous respect for the rights of the present non-Jewish inhabitants.

"The country has room for a larger population than it now contains, and Palestine, properly provided with roads, railways, harbors and electric power, with the soil more highly cultivated and waste lands reclaimed, forests planted and malaria extirpated, with town and village industries encouraged, can maintain a large additional population, not only without hurt, but on the contrary with much advantage to the present inhabitants.

"Immigration of the character that is needed will be admitted into the country in proportion as its development allows employment to be found. Above all, educational and spiritual influences will be fostered in the hope that once more there may radiate from the Holy Land the moral forces of service to mankind. These are the purposes which, under superintendence of the League of Nations, the British Government in the exercise of its mandate for Palestine will seek to promote."

Fourteen

If more conclusive evidence should be sought of Sir Herbert's understanding of and sympathy with Zionism, it will be found in the fact that, at the age of fifty, he has undertaken and apparently accomplished the task of mastering the Hebrew language! That fact will no doubt endear him to the Palestinian Jews, but if his object had been merely to gain popularity he could have found a less arduous means for attaining it. It is only necessary to point to the many prominent Zionists to whom Hebrew is still Greek to realize that Sir Herbert went to the trouble of learning the language because he perceived its significance for the land he is called upon to govern. The following bit of news, dated London, June 18th, bears testimony to his proficiency in the language of the national Jewish Homeland:

"In response to greetings from a delegation which, in the name of the Russian Zionists, presented Sir Herbert with a Scroll of the Law, the High Commissioner for Palestine replied in Hebrew. He said that he would take the Scroll of the Law with him to Palestine, and praised very highly the Russian Zionists."

The fear has been expressed by certain Zionists belonging to the “immediate Jewish State” school, that Herbert Samuel, by every token of his training and career, is a British, not a Jewish statesman, and would inevitably in all matters be guided by the interests of Great Britain only. Now, the writer is not one of those who can see nothing but halcyon days in the relations between England and the Jews in Palestine. There is bound to be more or less friction at various points. There is bound to be more or less friction between human beings who enter into any relationship whatsoever. No doubt there will be differences and grievances. It is clear, however, that at least in the beginning and perhaps for an indefinite time to come the differences should be harmonized at all costs. And it is exceedingly doubtful if a man could be found in whom the British and the Jewish viewpoints seem to be as organically harmonized as in Herbert Samuel.

Many months ago, before the name of Herbert Samuel was even mentioned in connection with Palestine, the writer heard a certain prominent Zionist, a man who passes for being shrewd and well-informed, express the opinion that it would be best for Zionism if the first man appointed to govern Palestine were a non-Jew. His reason was not the one usually given, namely, that a Jew, in his attempt not to appear pro-Jewish, would be actually anti-Jewish. His reason was: that the first governor would be bound to make a failure of the job and it would be better for such a failure to be associated with a non-Jew than with a Jew. Will Herbert Samuel make a successful governor of Palestine? We must leave prophecy to the prophets. One thing, however, is clear: Samuel is optimistic about Palestine and about his mission. Samuel did not assume his post before he had made a first hand study of what it involved. A man of the attainments and experience of Samuel can be depended upon to estimate with some exactitude the chances of success or failure of an undertaking like the one he is assuming. And it would clearly be unreasonable to suppose that after a brilliantly successful career, a man would assume a task which he believed would result in failure. Apparently Herbert Samuel is convinced that he is going to succeed. And the rest of us can do more than simply bid him God speed. The rest of us can contribute of what we are and of what we have to aid him to success in the arduous task he has undertaken in making of Palestine a real Jewish land.

July, 1920