The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXIII, No. 5 · June 1920
180printed page
scan 26 of 57
Facsimile · scan 26 of 57
Scan of p. 180
Text · transcribed from the scan

The Maccabaean

it is precisely in this respect that the Zionists can bring their greatest contribution to the efforts that are made in behalf of the oppressed Jews. For the Zionists are the only organized element in Jewry today with a correct and constructive point of view in regard to the Jewish situation and its various problems and complications. They understand, at least better than anybody else, what is the trouble and what should be done. Therefore it devolves upon them to place their better understanding at the service of the movement for the relief and liberation of those portions of our people that are abused, discriminated against, boycotted and massacred. This does not mean that the Zionists will have to alter or abandon any of their principles; not at all. They will simply have to apply their principles in an additional direction; they will have to take their constructive point of view, that supreme factor which differentiates them so decisively from all other elements in Jewry; they will have to take that point of view, that vision with which they illuminate the Zionist problems, and focus it as well on the Jewish problems in Eastern Europe.

In other words, the Zionists must inform the whole relief and emancipation work with a constructive spirit. For, strange as it is, we have come to a point where it is perfectly

apparent that the Zionists are the only ones who are in a position to contribute anything fundamental to the solution of the non-Zionist questions, such as the question of constructive relief, the question of our national and political rights in the golus countries, etc. Everybody contributed his share—individuals and organizations, self-appointed “diplomats” and chosen representatives, rabbis and financiers, elected bodies and unelected bodies, delegations and commissions, verbands, committees, councils and boards of deputies. Everybody has tried and everybody has failed. Because everybody felt charity, thought charity, had charity in his stock—and gave charity. Nobody had a constructive idea... And so “our poor brethren” got charity, charity, charity. But the Zionists have not tried. Individual Zionists have been and are in the work, but the Zionist Organization, the one national Jewish organization of international proportions and with a constructive national program, has not yet really made an effort. Yet upon that effort much depends. In it are involved, in a &ense, the future destinies of Zionism as well as the destinies of the starving, bleeding, brutally outraged Jewries in the lands of Eastern Europe. The time has arrived for the Zionists to give their somethines— which includes charity but is more than charity.

What Can Save the Jewish Congress?

(Continued from page 177)

to concern themselves with almost any question of Jewish life, economic political and cultural. Even the Federation of German Kehillahs or the Board of Deputies has also a large number of local internal problems to solve and this gives them strength and vitality. This insures them the support of the entire Jewish population.

The American Jewish Congress, however, has been built up on different principles. In the first place, it was a temporary affair, and secondly, its program was stripped of the most important and most pressing problems of Jewish life. If the program is not to include Palestine or cultural questions or the work of relief, then why should there be a Jewish Congress? It is enough to choose once and for all a commission which is to concern itself with protecting the interests of the Jews of the East and no more.

Is it possible for anyone to be vitally interested in a Congress without blood, without muscles, without a body?

There exist for the Jewish Congress only two roads: one, to dissolve itself, declaring that its mission has been fulfilled; second, to become a permanent institution, but first of all an institution of American Jews and for American Jews.

If the second road will be chosen, then necessarily all problems of Jewish life will have to be included.

This means: if the Jewish Congress wishes to continue its existence as a vital institution which shall not simply represent the Jewish people in America but proceed with all the work which is on the program of American Jewry, the principle must first of all be accepted that the Jewish Congress becomes permanent not because it is always necessary to protect the interests of the Jews of Eastern Europe or to stand on guard against infractions of the Peace Treaties, but

because the interests of the Jewish people in the United States—their political, social and national interests—demand a central institution which shall in America have the right to speak and to act in their name and concentrate around itself all national forces and institutions.

This means, in other words, that the Jewish Congress must take over the control of the Jewish educational institutions in the country, that it must take over and concentrate in its own hands the entire relief work for Eastern Europe, and that its task must embrace the protection of Jewish immigrants. Then it will be a living institution which meets certain real needs and not a platform for speeches and resolutions. It goes without saying that the Congress should take part in all questions, also, which concern world Jewry, and should participate in the future World Jewish Congress. This, however, is not all. In order to realize a program of such breadth and create for itself a healthy foundation, it must simultaneously decide to organize local Jewish kehillahs which shall either be elected by the whole Jewish population on the same principle as the Congress or consist of a conference of all local Jewish organizations, institutions and parties. Local executive committees should conduct all the local activities—look after education, aid immigrants, etc., and be the permanent link between the Congress and the Jewish masses.

Kehillahs or united Jewish committees in the various localities, and a permanent executive body in New York which shall respond to all the interests of American Jewry, such a national structure will stand firm and secure and grow naturally together with American Jewry. All compromises in this respect will only weaken the splendid and popular conception, because the institutions will then have no vitality.