The Maccabaean
Jewish Congress, to insure the success of the interests for which the Congress was created.
The situation is this: The most important part of the work under the political division is now accomplished; the work of the Relief Organizations cannot be transferred to the Congress; there are no new paths of activity for the Congress to enter; the Second Congress, or more accurately, the Second Assembly of the Jewish Congress, will, therefore, in all probability be the last. The democratic elements in the Congress must endeavor to make the Second Session as worthy and as harmonious a gathering as the First. The success of the Congress is ipso facto the success of the cause of democracy in American Jewish life.
This is what it will signify: At a great historic moment American Jewry united, under certain agreements, into an All-Jewish Congress, to effect specific objects. That Congress successfully accomplished what it set out to do. Then it adjourned and passed into history.
But the disbanding of the Congress need not mean the abandonment of the fight for the victory of democratic principles in American Jewish life. On the contrary, on the strength of the success of the democratic Jewish Congress—its great accomplishments and the worthiness of its existence—the democratic elements can and must continue the battle for democracy in Jewish public activities, with increased confidence and vigor.
How shall this come about? In what direction does the new way lead? What new form must the next coalition of democratic forces assume?
With the end of the Jewish Congress this must come from out of the democratic elements of the Congress itself.
Once democratic Jewry in America, has awakened—thanks to the Congress movement—to its rights and duties—to rights that ARE duties—in the leadership of general Jewish affairs in American Jewry, it is unthinkable that this democratic Jewry will be content even for a while, to leave the leadership of all general Jewish activities in the hands of the old, small minority. By this Jewish Congress the Jewish democracy took into its own hands, and openly proclaimed, its full citizenship in American Judaism. Now it can never relinquish those rights.
Jewish democracy would not do so even were this present hour in the life of the Jewish people not so tragic and critical, and so full of great historical possibilities, as it is. "The law of a single coin is one with the law of the hundred." Rights are rights irrespective of how great or petty are the interests involved. But especially under present conditions, the thinking and feeling Jewish democracy finds it impossible to step off the scene of Jewish public life even for a day.
For now, with the state of Jewish affairs as it is, and with the significance of American Jewry in the solution of the gigantic problems of the Jewish nation as marked as it is, the rights of the Jewish democracy are transformed into an earnest religious duty—to mount guard and take the post which belongs to it according to all the dictates of justice and democracy.
Those of our brethren, of the minority, who find it hard to free themselves of the old attitude that the voice of authority is the voice of the moneyed elite must come to understand and appreciate these facts.
And it is self-understood that the Congress delegates, representatives of the awakened self-consciousness of the broad Jewish masses, are the ones who are called upon to lay the foundation for the permanent organization of the
Jewish will on a democratic basis. This must take place not at the Congress, but after the Congress.
It would be a grave error, I believe, to attempt, at the very beginning, to create a specifically all-Jewish organization, and to become involved in long drawn-out negotiations—perhaps in unhealthy compromises—as was the case with the Jewish Congress.
The Congress movement had two central issues: to demand of the Peace Conference a national home in Palestine, and full equal rights in the other lands. These issues gave the Congress its immense strength. At the same time these issues forced a purely temporary character on the Congress. As soon as the Congress completed its task—to the extent which the task should have been undertaken—it became void of its content, and lost its previous significance.
A permanent organization cannot be founded on objectives which are temporary in character—be these objectives ever so great at the moment.
The upbuilding of the promised Jewish Homeland, and the work of relief, in all its forms, are great tasks, deserving of the concentrated eflort of the whole nation. Yet we hope for the day when Palestine will not require the organized help of extra-Palestinian Jewry; and the need of large-scale relief work will disappear sooner or later— let us hope sooner. Political activity for insuring the equal rights of Jews in enemy lands, after these rights have been lesally secured, will also need less attention as time eoes on.
On the other hand we are faced with purely American Jewish problems of a religious, cultural and social character which are of a permanent nature, but which cannot at this moment be raised as great issues. In time they will present themselves for earnest consideration, although at this moment they must be kept in the background, in order to release the great and pressing national problems.
The justification of a permanent organization, therefore, is seen to lie in the totality of problems of Jewish life—the all-Jewish as well as the particular American—those that endure together with those that pass away. The call for such an organization cannot come in the name of one task or another, but only in the name of the principle of democracy in Jewish life. The great historical significance of this hour for the Jewish future makes it highly imperative that this battle for democracy be not stayed nor postponed. The will of the people and the energy of the nation must assert themselves immediately to the extent to which they have been awakened; they must be further roused where they lie dormant.
It is very clear that all those elements of Jewry which do not wish to share the burden of the totality of Jewish problems, or those which do not believe that the time for democracy in American Jewish life has arrived, will not join the new organization. The new organization therefore will not be able to speak in the name of the whole Community of Israel of America. Before all else there must be honesty—to oneself and to the world. The new organization cannot now be a Jewish Congress or a Jewish national council, though it can and should become such a body in good time. At present it can be no more than the Jewish league of democracy of America.
This league will be a constructive, not a destructive power. It will unite all Jewish democratic forces, now wandering aimlessly on many different roads, for the accomplishment of Jewish work. It will gladly co-operate with other organizations of different beliefs, whenever it can bring the will of the people to full action.
