The Maccabaean
contractor had to bring in other workmen for this part of the job.
I discussed this matter with a member of Hapoel Hazair. How, I asked, can the principle of “only Jewish labor” be carried out in view of the above circumstances? He replied that despite their lack of knowledge of any particular skilled work, Jewish workmen should be employed in order to learn that work. The contractor in the above case is in fact prepared to teach Jews (which, of course, involves the employment of non-Jewish foremen), but the point may well be made—are all works promoted by the Zionist Organization to suffer in order that Jewish laborers may be taught skilled branches of building, etc? Granted that we are prepared to incur the extra cost involved, will the Government give us concessions for public works under those conditions?
The ideal of the Jewish workman, who asserts that only by labor shall Israel be saved, is a noble one; I am only concerned in pointing to the difficulties that his policy entails.. Practical experience shows that to interpret it literally means that Secharo yese b’hefsido (the gain will be swallowed by the loss). But even if it were possible to employ Jews only in all industrial as well as agricultural enterprises without heavy losses, what is likely to be the effect of such a policy on the Government and on the non-Jewish inhabitants of Palestine? Can it be reconciled with the ofhicial policy of preserving the most friendly relations with our Arab neighbors? There are those who think that this and similar problems created by the presence X an Arab majority in Palestine should be solved by a mass immigration of Jews, which in a few years would cormvert the majority into a minority. But supposing that policy to be practical, there still remains the consideration—generally ignored by writers outside Palestine—that to silence the complaints of Arabs by swamping the country with Jews means hastening a much more serious problem, viz., that of our relations with our neighbors on each side of Palestine. It is true that the fellah in Egypt and Syria has nothing vital in common with the fellah in Palestine today, but that attempts to create bonds between the Moslems of all three countries will be made is undoubted; the Arab kingdom may indeed encourage such relations. It is obvious, therefore, that the directors of Jewish policy in Erez Israel will bear a serious responsibility if their actions result in embittering the fellah, and cause him to turn a willing ear to those agitators for a “United Syria” who are allied to him by religion, and to whom so far he has made but a slight response.
On the cultural and social relations between Jew and Arab I hope to write on another occasion.
THE POLITICAL SITUATION
Since Dr. Weizmann’s last visit to Palestine the attitude of the British authorities here toward Zionist activity has distinctly improved. The Zionist Commission has been able to open preliminary negotiations for leasing certain lands; afforestation has begun at Nahlat Yehuda on the sand dunes given to Rishon-le-Zion by the Turkish Government, and new immigrants have been organized into Kevuzoth for this and other agricultural work. The energy of Mr. Ussishkin has expressed itself in several directions, and on the whole a more favorable atmosphere has succeeded the depression of some months ago. Yet it would appear that until a Civil Administration, obliged and em-
powered to carry out the Balfour Declaration in the spirit as well as in the letter, succeeds the present temporary military occupation, Jewish national enterprises and interests will still be hindered by local difficulties.. Thus it is sometimes found impossible to carry out important Zionist work for which the consent of the administration has been secured. While the terms of the Mandate for Palestine are still unconfirmed, it is not surprising to find many minor ofhcials yielding to the clamor of Arab agitators, who continually remind the authorities of their obligation’ to preserve the siatus quo. For the Arab situation does not improve as time passes, and as joyfully as the Jews look forward to the coming of Mr. Herbert Samuel—who has arrived at Cairo—the Arab journalists and clubs may be expected proportionately to increase their opposition to Zionism. When the notorious Suria Al Junobia can presume to congratulate the Government on appointing a successor to Colonel Bentwich, Senior Judicial Officer (who has really only left the country on leave of absence) because the latter was a leading Zionist, and can in effect invite its readers to imitate the “nationalists’”” of Shechem, who have instituted a boycott against the Jews, it is no exaggeration to say that the question of Arab relations with Jews has become serious. I understand, indeed, that steps are being taken to improve Ihe position, and they will not be too soon. In this connection our brethren, the Sephardim, can help greatly. Speaking Arabic, and in several ways in close contact with the Arabs, they have opportunities of drawing them closer to us that are denied to the Ashkenazim. Sephardi Jews are also not so ex treme in their nationalism as to repel the Palestinian Arab, who has just begun to suspect the European Zionist. Our policy should also provide for closer social co-operation between Western and Sephardi Jews; as a consequence the former would learn more thoroughly to appreciate Arab conditions, their mentality and customs, while the localborn Jews would gain moral support and a knowledge of European methods and manners.
At Haifa, a proposal has been made by the Military Governor to found a School and a Club, to be patronized by all sections of the population. Preliminary meetings to discuss the matter have been held, in which Jewish representatives have participated, but no decision has a yet been taken. The idea is certainly inspiring, and must appeal to many who feel that a prosperous Palestine can be possible only on the basis of co-operation between all races. But there is another view, expressed by Mr. Jabotinsky, that deserves consideration. Inasmuch as we have come to Palestine to redeem the soul of the nation, to recreate our national culture, we cannot, he says, afford to forego the principle that all our Schools must be Hebrew in spirit as well as language. After all. we are the only people who have created the beginnings of a culture in Palestine, and we are justified in concentrating our whole energy on strengthening those spiritual foundations. A mixed school in his opinion will be unsuccessful, as similar ex periments in Russia and Germany have proved. This argument against the School does not perhaps hold good against the joint Club. Such an “international” Club has existed in Hebron, and the advantages of that intercourse between Jews, Arabs and Christians which it would afford are obvious, provided of course that all members are animated by the same sincere feelings of fraternity. m .17 Fr .ı ie 2 ug 93 En «
The wilder spirits among the Arabs to the north of
