The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXIII, No. 4 · April 1920
124printed page
scan 6 of 40
Facsimile · scan 6 of 40
Scan of p. 124
Text · transcribed from the scan

The Maccabaean

parage Zionism, to attack and refute its tenets with acrimonious harshness and animosity, or, in papers of lower standing, to sneer at them in approved anti-Semitic style, and often go largely out of their way to create such opportunity or pretext. I don't think I libel these militant Catholics if I say that they are behind the anti-Zionist and anti-Jewish agitation carried on by a group of Syrians, their coreligionaries who pretend to resist our claim to Palestine in the name of the rights of the Arab nation, and that their show of exacerbated pan-Arab nationalism is only a disguise of their clericalism.

We cannot shut our eyes to the fact that the Catholic Church pretends to the overlordship in Palestine. The Holy See considers itself as the legitimate successor of Constantine the Great and as the legal heir of the Crusaders, possessors of the land by right of conquest. Since united Italy has elevated Rome to her capital there have been voices raised repeatedly in the Vatican which pleaded for the transfer of the supreme government of the Church to Jerusalem. The sovereignty of the Pope over the Holy Land would find enthusiastic approval with the powerful clerical parties of France, Spain, Italy, not to speak of the Catholics, by no means negligible, of Belgium, Switzerland, Germany, Poland, and also England, Ireland, Canada and the United States. In France the clerical party wields great, often decisive, political influence, particularly in foreign affairs, in spite of the official laxity of the republic, of the separation of State and Church, and of the suppression of the Embassy at the Vatican. We must never forget the well-known word of Gambetta: "Anti-clericalism is not an article of export." In fact, the tenacity with which France in 1916 and later defended her position in near Asia against England, insisted upon a privileged status in Syria and in as much of Palestine as possible, and constantly spoke in high sounding terms of her determination to safeguard her patrimony of historic influence in those countries, finds its explanation in the views and intentions of the clericals who in this case act as allies of the government, the Catholics affirming that they work for the extension of French prestige, influence and language in the world, and the republicans accepting this co-operation and reciprocating it by supporting the Catholics abroad.

With this state of things, it is obvious that the Catholic Church must consider us as intruders and will oppose itself secretly and perhaps openly to our establishment, and later to our sovereignty in Palestine. Zionism has no desire to enter into a conflict with Rome. It has every interest and will do all in its power to avoid it from the outset. We seek an understanding with the Church. Herzl always put stress on his intention to recognize the extra-territorial character of the holy places in the Jewish State. I go, and always went, much farther than my great friend. I do not consider Jerusalem as essential for the Jewish State. I am quite ready to renounce its possession. I know the retort would be: "So you preconize Zionism without Zion." I do. Let Christianity have its own way with full freedom in Jerusalem. What we Jews need and want is agricultural land. Some greater towns, sure to develop quickly and vigorously, such as Jaffa, Haifa, Jericho, would amply suffice for those activities and institutions which require centralization, urban surroundings and the presence of numerous highly cultivated professional men, and would be ac-

ceptable seats of the administrative, judicial and military authorities, the Parliament, the high schools, the museums, the theatres, the banks. But I am aware that my proposal is not likely to find a ready response with our masses, who are more inclined to follow sentimental impulses than rational considerations. If we cannot purely and simply give up Jerusalem, abandoning it unreservedly to the Church as Italy has abandoned to it the Vatican quarter in the Trastevere of Rome, we must at least give the concept of the extra-territoriality of the holy places such an ample meaning that the Catholics shall never be justified in complaining of Jewish interference with them. They must not feel themselves in a subordinate situation around the Saint Sepulcre or the Dormition, the Mount of Olives or Golgotha, which they would resent and for which they would try to make our brothers abroad, however assimilated, pay heavily.

With Protestantism, as with the minor Christian denominations, the Armenians, the Nestorians, the Maronites, the Copts, the Chaldeans, the Abyssinians, we ought to be able to establish and maintain the best of relations but for one cause, which, I am afraid, is pregnant with trouble. This cause is that of the missionaries.

The Protestant Missions in Palestine—the heathen missions in the farther east and the south of Asia, in Africa and Australia, are no concern of ours—are avowedly intended for the turning away of Jews from their faith. They rarely, if ever, undertake to convert Mohammedans. The chosen field of their activity is the Jewish community. They fish for Jewish souls. They bring to bear their art and industry, their seductions and material enticements, on Jews, whom they do their best to induce to deny their faith, their traditions, their people, their national solidarity. If they only employed spiritual means, we could meet them with the same means; it would be a fair fight with equal weapons. But the Missions ask for special privileges. They have been able to introduce in the draft of the Mandate an article granting them expressly the right of acquiring land for schools, hospitals, assembly halls, etc., necessary or useful for their purposes, and of practising freely their converting activity. This is a humiliation which we cannot suffer. In our own land we can have no privileged adversaries holding an international brief for combating and debasing our faith and for teaching our children to have contempt for their parents and brothers. If they desire to live among us, they are free to do so. But no special privilege for them. This is inadmissible.

These are the difficulties arising from our cohabitation with other religions which we will have to face in Jewish Palestine. It goes without saying that we will practise unlimited toleration. This virtue need not be preached to us Jews. We have it in the blood. It is part of our nature. We will be firm in our rights, but modest in their outward affirmation. We will never be aggressive against other faiths, but limit ourselves to the defense of our own, the energy of which defense will be proportionate with the violence or malice of the attack.

With these principles on these lines we hope to succeed in steering clear of the dangerous cliffs and rocks which loom in our sea route to the Jewish State in Palestine.

London, February 17, 1920.