The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXIII, No. 4 · April 1920
148printed page
scan 30 of 40

The Meeting of the Greater Actions Committee

BEFORE aught else: The Greater Actions Committee, after twenty years of functioning under that style and title, is to be known hereafter as the Executive Council of the Zionist Organization. Its recent London gathering will go down in history as the last Zionist assembly of any importance before the rise of the curtain which at the time of this writing still veils the Palestinian deliberations of the Peace Conference. It was an impressive and emotionally affecting post-bellum meeting of friends who, for five years on end, had to keep apart with a raging sea of hostile nationalism between them and their reunion. For the Stimmungsbild of the London session we refer the reader to Mr. Israel Cohen's European Letter in this issue. In this place, we are concerned with the detail of its transactions.

The most important of its daily gatherings was that of February 16—Palestine Day. On that day Mr. Sokolow, the first speaker, struck the keynote of good cheer by reporting his audience with Paul Deschanel, an interview productive of an interimistic entente cordiale between Zionism and the French government. After his report began the Palestine debate. In the first place, Julius Simon, who is now in America, outlined the Palestinian land-policy agreed upon in the Fall between the A. C. and the American delegation to London under the leadership of Justice Brandeis. These outlines were supplemented through the reading of a number of expert-opinions elaborated by an Advisory Committee under the chairmanship of Mr. Herbert Samuel. Mr. Ruppin then called the attention of the A. C. to the fact that the American Organization, for some time to come, will have the decisive say in land-policies because of the depreciation of the Central European and Eastern valuta, which inevitably must throw the main financial burden of the settlement to come upon Western shoulders until betterment of conditions in the European East accompanied by a rise of the valuta. Dr. Bodenheim insisted upon the necessity of securing, on principle, sole possession of the land to the National Fund. Boris Goldberg made a spirited plea for giving room to private initiative in the redemption of the soil. Naiditsch countered with an impassioned retort. It is infinitely less important, he said, to organize private exploits than to strengthen the National Fund. In a conciliatory speech, Weizmann agreed that the inspirational value of the N. F. as a truly democratic institution must be regarded the central factor in the upbuilding and all others considered subsidiary. The greatest impelling force, he declared, in the gathering of funds will be the propaganda of action in Palestine. Dr. Halpern called attention to the necessity of strictly distinguishing between donations and funds from financial institutes secured on a business-like basis, the latter supremely necessary no matter what volume of donations may pour in. To this Podliszewski partly assented, stressing, however, the necessity of national control over private concerns. He furthermore urged the institution of liquidation-banks and other measures to render possible the liquidation of the estates of emigrants from Eastern Europe. Feiwel dwelt upon the importance of distinguishing sharply between profit-yielding and non-profit-yielding enterprises in Palestine, so that the former may all the more readily be financed from the outside.

One Hundred Forty-Eight

On February 17 the Palestine debate was continued. Solomon Goldberg delivered an interesting address concerning the dominating rôle of the American Jewry in Zionist work and upon the attitude of American non-Zionist circles. An argument between Sprinzak and Lime made it clear that most delegates looked upon acquirement of the soil, apart from colonization-work, as the sole legitimate function of the National Fund. From this view Boehm dissented. He saw no deterrent to private capital in a colonization management of the National Fund. All speakers agreed upon the necessity of liquidation-banks in Eastern Europe, to be financed from London. Sacher, just returned from Palestine, spoke about the necessity of taking in hand public works and about the impossibility of eliminating private enterprise from the work of rebuilding the land. The necessity of training human material continuously and systematically in the Diaspora was urged by Stricker. Warburg and Naiditsch agreed upon the immediate actuality of the question of public works financed by private enterprise. This position was modified by Friedeman's warning that public works cannot be taken in hand before political guarantees have been rendered definite. The evening session was concluded by a speech of Weizmann's describing at length the present-day situation in Palestine and giving an account of the relations of the Zionist Commission toward the British administration and the Arab population. The tone and temper of the discussions were in a desirable vein of matter-of-factness throughout, without rhetoric—and apart from a few strictures of the Mizrachi representative, Rabbi Schoenfeld—without bitterness.

THE RESOLUTION OF THE CONFERENCE

The following is a complete list of the resolutions passed at various sittings of the Conference:

AT THE POLITICAL DEBATE

Proposed by Dr. Klee:

After hearing the speeches of Dr. Weizmann and Nahum Sokolow, the Executive Council expresses its unbounded confidence in the Executive and especially in Dr. Weizmann and Nahum Sokolow, and its deep gratitude for the self-sacrificing and successful work which they have carried out on behalf of the Zionist ideals; and it empowers the Executive to continue its work along its present political lines.

Proposed by Dr. Levin:

The Executive Council asks the Zionist Organization of America to appoint at least two representatives to the Executive and two representatives to the Zionist Commission.

ON EDUCATIONAL WORK

Proposed by Dr. Levin:—

1. The Executive Council approves the program submitted to it for beginning the University, according to which the University will at the start be opened with research institutes in the natural sciences (for physics, chemistry, microbiology, and agriculture), a Hebrew institute and a general lectureship in philosophical subjects. At the same time, chairs are to be attached to it for pedagogy and Jewish subjects, by means of which the teachers for the Hebrew training colleges and secondary schools will be trained. This beginning shall at an early date be developed into a complete University.