The Maccabaean
of respecting natural frontiers, followed the artificial boundaries of Turkish vilayets.
Turkish vilayets. The fountains of the Jordan and the Litany happened to be in the Turkish province of Beirut, and as France was to have oversight of the port of Beirut, the southern declivities of Mount Lebanon and Mount Hermon were assigned to France, although not economically related to Beirut. One can imagine the negotiators, working hastily and not having in mind the recreation of Palestine, putting a ruler on the map and arbitrarily saying that the dividing line should run straight east from north to Haifa.
Engineers unite in declaring that regeneration will be difficult, if not impossible, unless the unwatered regions to the south are moistened by the now wasted northern waters. The first big task of the new state should be to impound the upper Jordan and the Litany. But this cannot well be done on territory not controlled and unpoliced.
No special reason is advanced why France should refuse to revise the boundary. The transferred streams do not flow up hill, and thus are of no use to Lebanon and Syria. Yet between nations, even the most friendly, there is displayed an ungenerous spirit. Britain's interest in an autonomous Palestine may be deemed by some French diplomatists to be a reason for perpetuating Palestine's mutilation. If any such feeling exists, may the French government not allow it to control. The warm friends of France in this country join their solicitations to those who want the Palestine experiment to have freest chance to succeed, and to redeem, restored to human use, an area which once sustained many millions and is capable of doing the same again.
THE SYRIAN INTERMEZZO AND THE SHADOW OF "JEHAD"
That East is East and West is West and that the twain will never meet, is now a discredited poetic legend. The twain have met in the person of Emir Feisal, who kept on, for thirteen months, io talk Western ambiguities with an amazing knack of following the verbal twinings and finessings of Occidental diplomacy, to top the performance with a sudden coup d’etat planned and executed in true Asiatic fashion. While the Peace Conference, all through the month of March, was busy composing an appalling jumble of conflicting claims upon Ottoman territory; while the Zionist and the general press of Europe and America were battering the Conference doors with the heavy artillery of Syrian frontier arguments; while the Jewish world-community was straining its auditory sense listening for any sounds coming forth from the Gates of Entente Decision—this astonishing Eastern potentate broke through the tension of suspense by proclaiming himself King of Syria and his brothers Abdullah and Sayd as King and Regent of Irak and Mesopotamia, accompanying his proclamation with protestations of continued friendliness to the Allies. It must have taken the Emir a long time to set the stage for this dramatic coup. There must have been some sort of understanding with that infamous Young Turk bandit who is playing now at independent royalty in the hills of Kurdistan. There may have been understandings with the Sultan and with disaffected Egypt. Less likely but possibly, there may have been understandings with the Moslem heretics of Persia and Afghanistan. That he has no choice before him but fight or complete submission to the Western Powers in view of their stern refusal to accept ihe situation of his creating, is of course patent to the Emir, despite his protestations of friendship. Under the circumstances, is the world to believe that he faced this alternative in the prospect without a most thorough preparation, in profound secrecy, for fight? Fight, under the circumstances means Jehad—a holy war of the Moslem world rising against foreign domination. This particular Jehad—if not suppressed in the
bud—may easily reach westward to Tunis, eastward to the Punjab and northward to Turkestan. Meantime, the Entente Powers, according to the newspapers, have cited the Emir before the Conference to justify himself if he can—more likely to be severely disciplined if he pays heed to the summons. His choice clearly lies between Jehad and self-surrender. Whatever alternative he embraces, the chances for Zionist aspirations toward a just Palestinian frontier are splendidly improved. To discuss them in an anticipatory vein is a moral impossibility. Events, more over, are likely to outrun discussion. Whatever turn the Syrian situation takes, the Passover week of 1920 bids fair to be a noteworthy one in Jewish history.
MEGILLATH POLAND
At the time of this writing, there trickles through successive issues of the American Hebrew the spiritless current of Mr. Morgenthau’s Polish relazioni. (Bythe-by: To judge from the pages of that press-product, the last available proofreader in New York City must have joined the ranks of Zionism, forswearing all professional relations with hostile periodicals.) The editor of our contemporary, the New York Jewish Tribune, has lost all patience with that remarkablv able but thoroushlv un-Jewish versonalitv:
“An der Jacke der Geduld Rissen ihm die Knoepfe ploetzlich.”
He calls Mr. Morgenthau's report—irrelevantly, we think—a "Betrayal of the Jews"—which it can't be, seeing that Mr. Morgenthau did not receive his inquisitorial mandate from any Jewish group. However, it may justly be called a betrayal of the best interests of America and Europe alike, seeing that the relator urges the advisability of a substantial American loan to Poland not made contingent upon better guarantees for protection of its national minorities. While Mr. Morgenthau is busy attempting to finance a few more Lembergs and Pinsks with American dollars, the Polish list of physical, moral and economic pogroms lengthens endlessly. A few only of the latest items are subjoined. According to the Chicago Sentine'—
Stormy debates took place at the Polish Parliament on the occasion of the passage of the Bill relating to Polish Citizenship. According to the new law only inhabitants of Poland actually registered as permanent residents of a town will be regarded as Polish citizens. The Jewish amendment proposed by Deputy Greenbaum to the effect that all persons who resided in Poland on the 1st of August. 1914. should be recognized as citizens was rejected. The speeches of Deputies Greenbaum and Hirshorn which were interrupted by anti-Semitic outcries had little effect on the solid majority against theJewish standpoint. Mr. Greenbaum again had an angry dispute with the President of the Parliament and persistent demands were made by many deputies to exclude him from the sitting.
After the vote on the Bill had been taken the Jewish deputies submitted to the House a protest against its decision. It was pointed out to the Chamber that during the Russian rule in Poland the registration now demanded as a proof of eitizenship was valueless and that the Jews had no occasion and little facilities to register themselves. The New Bill is therefore a blow to the Jews of old Russian Poland, who suddenly become aliens and whose houses are now liable to be “requisitioned” by the Police for Government purposes, whilst they themselves may expect to be expelled from Warsaw. The Jewish deputies also characterized the new law as a breach of the Peace Treaty. The Orthodox leader and Polish patriot, Deputy Rabbi Halpern also signed the protest.
From the London Jewish Chronicle we glean the following: