The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXIII, No. 4 · April 1920
141printed page
scan 23 of 40

The Maccabaean

ganda will still have to be carried on by the Jewish National Fund in order to ensure that public opinion on the question of the Jewish national ownership of the land shall be as effective as any law of the Jewish Commonwealth until the latter becomes a possibility.

Opinions varied as to the sum for which an appeal should be issued in order to obtain the requisite resources for the upbuilding of the Jewish Palestine, and opinions likewise varied as to whether the sum to be raised should be a freewill offering or a loan. Eventually a compromise was arrived at: it was resolved that the sum of £25,000,000 should be raised, and that a distinction should be made between money that will be given as voluntary contributions and "investments in which capital and interest are secured on ordinary business lines." So far as matters of organization are concerned the three most important resolutions were: to invite the Zionist Organization of America to appoint two representatives on the Zionist Commission, to increase the membership of the Zionist Commission to thirteen, and to hold the deferred "Annual" Conference at the beginning of next July. The place of meeting of the Conference is left to the discretion of the Executive, but a recommendation was adopted that it should be held in a country with a low rate of exchange; and there is much to be said in favor of holding it in a place like Carlsbad, which is practically as accessible as Basle, whilst it would enable a far larger number of delegates from Central and Eastern Europe to attend and at not such a high rate of cost as in Switzerland. The Conference passed off without "scenes," as the word is understood in the political world. On the contrary, it concluded with an appreciable increase of confidence in the leaders and with an unmistakable feeling of optimism. This spirit will be conveyed by the various delegates to their respective centers and the result will be to infuse new hope and courage into the waiting millions.

As for the Mandate, the central pivot upon which everything practical now turns, we are still awaiting its coming. It would be useless to indulge in further prophecy, since the Peace Conference is apparently trying to create a record for duration. But as the complete text of the Treaty with Turkey is promised for three weeks hence, it seems quite likely that the issuing of the Mandate may synchronize with Passover. No happier coincidence could be conceived, but the workings of the Peace Conference are laborious and involved, and much seems to depend upon events outside the Conference Chamber. The delay is doing no good either to our cause or to Palestine itself, for the malcontents in the country are profiting thereby, to foment agitation and to exaggerate an opposition which is not shared by the great bulk of the population. But the harm is not confined to Palestine; mischief is also done here by reckless speeches by Mr. Zangwill and others, which are accepted by the Arabs as the official utterances of Zionist leaders. And the Anglo-Jewish press has also not been helpful, however well-intentioned its criticism may be. The necessity has thus manifested itself of having in England a new Jewish weekly which shall represent the official Zionist point of view. The matter has been discussed at intervals during the last six

April, 1920

months or so, but the discussion is at last crystallizing into concrete steps.

There was one subject that engaged the attention of the Zionist Executive to which I have not yet made any reference, namely, the work of the Committee of Jewish Delegations in Paris. This body is no Committee of the Zionist Organization, but it is to the latter that most of the credit is due for its formation and its steady productive activity. Had it not been for the steps taken by the Zionist delegates in Paris, it is doubtful if the various Jewish delegations that came to lay their plaints before the Peace Conference would have been fused into a single working organism. Mr. Leo Motzkin, the Secretary-General of the Committee, delivered a very interesting summary of the Committee’s activities during the last twelve months and foreshadowed the work of the future. His report served as a necessary corrective to the printed Report just issued by the Joint Foreign Committee of the Jewish Board of Deputies and the Anglo-Jewish Association. According to the latter document, informative and well-written as it is, one would imagine that everything done at the Peace Conference for the benefit of oppressed Jewry was the work of the Joint Foreign Committee. However salutary the efforts of the Anglo-Jewish Delegation may have been, it is neither just nor wise to ignore the contributions of other Jewish Delegations to the general result. But the Joint Foreign Committee is evidently seized with insensate jealousy, or is sufferine from overweenine pride.

A few weeks ago the Board of Deputies passed, with a very large majority, a resolution in favor.of instructing its delegates on the Joint Committee to co-operate with the Committee of Jewish Delegations.. There was a marked cleavage in the voting: the majority was Zionist, including the chairman, Sir Stuart Samuel. But what happened next? The Joint Foreign Committee, comprising representatives both of the Anglo-Jewish Association and of the Board of Deputies, took up the resolution, as though it had been referred to it, and decided by 9 votes to 3 that the application of the resolution should be postponed for the present. Now, one would have imagined that the Board of Deputies would have been furious at the manner in which its resolution was thus frustrated; for it was neither necessary nor constitutional for the Deputies’ delegates on the Joint Committee to discuss the matter with the delegates of the Anglo-Jewish Association. But no, the protests were quite few and mild, and the Deputies did not realize that they had been bamboozled by a cunning man&uvre. A compromise, however, was arrived at by Sir Stuart Samuel accepting the direct invitation of the Committee of Delegations to co-operate with it. Even for this Lord Rothschild seemed to think that the approval of the Joint Foreign Committee was necessary. There may not appear to be anything great at stake in this matter—except principle. But there is one conclusion that has become obvious: that the Jewish Board of Deputies, the only democratic and representative Jewish body in this country, must shake off the incubus of its unnecessary and irregular union with the Anglo-Jewish Association.

London, March 5, 1920.
One Hundred Forty-One