The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXIII, No. 4 · April 1920
138printed page
scan 20 of 40

The Maccabaean

spectacle of tenacious national mourning that had not its like on earth. What impressed him most was the fact that the mourners had very little in common apart from their millennial grievance—in physique, bearing, dress, manners, everyday morals—above all, in language, they were a Babel of confusion: Ashkenazim, Sephardim, natives, Yemenites, Bocharese, black Falashas—Chassidim, Misnagdim, men of wealth, schnorrers, sophisticated scholars and unlettered rabble—a fantastic jumble of types, ranks, beliefs, tongues, gestures—in short, galuth in Jerusalem, without common work, a common tongue, a common place of worship. Then and there, in front of the Wall of Wailing, on the spot where the national Holy of Holies stood in the ancient times, a grand conceit took hold of him—he would build a magnificent Temple in Jerusalem, at the very spot of wailing, larger, grander, costlier, more imposing than any the world has ever seen—a new Solomonic edifice, planned and erected by the world’s greatest architects, ornamented by the world’s greatest artists, a devotional center for all Jewish tribes, factions, creeds, constructed in keeping with Biblical precepts and descriptions.

“To realize his concept, the Baron turned to some of the world’s greatest architects, inviting them to travel all over the globe, to study the world’s architectural marvels—synagogues, churches, mosques—and then to submit to him competitive sketches of the Third Temple projected at Jerusalem. You are now looking upon their efforts immortalized on parchment. There was nothing in the way of the new Solomon of the West—except the Turkish Government. Listen—

"The Rothschilds were of good credit and repute with the Sublime Porte, which often needed them in their difficulties. It was easy enough for Baron Edmond to obtain an audience from Abdul Hamid. The Sultan listened politely to his prayer for a permission to build on holy ground an eighth world-wonder for the Jews, at an enormous expense to be borne entirely by the Baron. He said he would take the matter under advisement—and there the matter rested. For months the Baron kept on urging, but the Sultan, under some polite pretext or other, refused to commit himself—he knew very well why. For the old fox, never on satisfactory terms with the Arabs of Palestine, was mortally afraid of their jealousy in the matter of concessions to the Jew. Furthermore, he looked upon temple-building on such a tremendous scale as a distinctly Zionistic move, apt to set a heretofore unheard-of yishub into motion. In short, he looked upon the new Solomonic Temple to be erected as a snare and a certain source of future embarrassments, and the building permit was never given. Meantime, the Baron had spent several hundred thousand francs on the planning embodied in three portfolios of which the volume you hold in your hand is one.

"Let no one say that his dream has not come true. There is, after all, only one Temple in which Jews of all shades of belief and disbelief can be gathered in—the Hebrew University at Jerusalem which is now in process of erection. That the University was really the Temple of his dreams, the Baron understood at once, as soon as he received word of the project. His son, carrying a circulandum-letter to the colonists, represented him at the connerstone-laying. The letter, delivered by the son in person last Rosh-Hashonah, read as follows:

"To the colonies in Eretz-Yisroel, Rishon-le-Zion, Petach-Tikvah, and Ekron, greeting:

"At the threshold of a New Year of most auspicious forebodings for the entire Jewish people, give me leave to transmit to you my blessings and the assurance of my unflagging interest in your work and welfare. The bearer of these presents, my son, is authorized both to speak and to listen to you in my name, to deliver my messages and to receive yours. Among the comforts of my old age the foremost is this: that I have a son both willing and able to continue worthily the giant task of rebuilding Eretz-Yisroel—a labor begun in my own days and to be carried on now on a grander and more satisfactory scale. Rest assured that my son's heart, like my own, is altogether devoted to the work in hand."

"At the foundation-laying in Jerusalem, a stone was laid in honor of the Baron. What say you now—has his dream been empty air?" The old librarian looked at me with a quizzical smile as he took the portfolio of parchments out of my hand, carefully shelving his treasure. "To my mind, certainly not. There won't be a Jewish rival of Caliph Omar's mosque—but there will be an alma mater drawing to itself students from New York, Buenos Aires, London, Algiers, Odessa, Constantinople, Cairo, Johannesburg, Bombay, Melbourne—from all spots on earth where Hebrew has not died off the lips of living men—and great teachers are better national investments than gorgeous copulas and mural decorations. I think the Baron has now a new opportunity afforded him for gifts on a grand scale."

VI

For all his ready openhandedness, the Baron, after a first ingathering of experience in settlement-policies, was by no means "easy." He could say "no," with a decisive argument to back up his "no," any time the occasion required it. As for instance:

The settlers of Rishon-le-Zion wanted water-pipes in their houses—an unheard-of thing in Palestinian village-life. They had estimates made for them, and it appeared that the installation of water-pipes would cost 70,000 francs. The settlers appealed to Baron Edmond for a loan to that amount, and were refused in a letter containing this noteworthy bit of chiding:

"The colonists of Rishon-le-Zion have evidently learnt to think scorn of our arch-mother Rebecca who went to the well, pitcher on her head. I do not say that the proposed installation of water-pipes is not a desirable comfort—it is. But it is a comfort belonging to that advanced stage of colonial development when the municipality of Rishon-le-Zion will be able to pay for it by levy and assessment, without recourse to reckless borrowing. . . ." You may be sure, the Rishon-le-Zionites knew that they were answered.

Another instance of the Baron's resolute demeanor in the face of colony-sentiment going astray:

There was a time when the new "landlord" element in Petach-Tikvah imagined it could at one and the same time exploit Zionist sentiment all over the world—and the Baron's helpfulness as well—and draw its labor chiefly or exclusively from Arab sources. We, the young radical land-workers of Petach-Tikvah, saw with growing indignation, what was going on. The "planter" element, at one time, sent messengers abroad to the Zionist world-organization and to Baron Edmond in Paris, for the ingathering of subsidies, in the name of their holy cause of rebuilding Eretz-Yisroel. At the same time, they discharged as many