The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXIII, No. 3 · March 1920
82printed page
scan 4 of 40

The Maccabaean

Underwood & Underwood

Remarkable and Historic Photograph Taken During the First Meeting of the League of Nations in the Cloak Room of the French Foreign Office on the Quai d'Orsay, Paris, January 16, 1920, Showing the Delegates. Seated at the Big Table, Left to Right, Facing Front: Premier Venizelos of Greece (Extreme Left, Resting Head on Hand); Dr. Cunba of Brazil; M. Satusi of Japan; Lord Curzon of England; Leon Bourgeois, New President of the French Senate and Permanent Chairman of the League of Nations; Ferraria of Italy; Paul M. Hymans of Belgium, and Guiones de Lien of Spain.

country entrusted to its care, and the League of Nations will then have to decide whether it will admit into its circle that country as a new member on terms of equality, or whether it will judge this honor premature and not yet fully deserved, and decree another term of observation and expectation.

It is not known at present whether a date will be assigned to the end of England's mandate for the administration of Palestine, or whether the mandatory power will be free to prolong or shorten the exercise of its right according to its own judgment. One limitation, however, is from the outset, it is understood, put on the mandate: England is to administer Palestine with a view to giving the Jews an opportunity for "establishing there a national home for the Jewish people."

The formula, "a national home," has been the subject of manifold and widely diverse interpretation. I read it as meaning an autonomous Jewish State and so does every political Zionist. I have discussed the matter elsewhere and do not wish to enlarge upon it here. But what I think necessary is to draw attention to certain other expressions used for the first time officially by non-Zionists, by non-Jews, in Mr. Balfour's declaration and presumably taken over literally into the article of the international agreement which will define the mandate of England, the words "a national home for the Jewish people."

So Mr. Balfour first, and all the powers represented in the League of Nations after him, speak of the "Jewish people," recognize explicitly the existence of a Jewish peo-

Eighty-Two

ple. This authoritatively puts an end to the controversy whether the Jews form a people, as we Zionists maintain, or whether they are only a religious community without another bond but their faith, in the same way as the Catholics, the Mohammedans, or the Buddhists.

A whole library has been written on this question. The most subtle, most intricate argument has been brought to bear on the subject. Sincere seekers of truth and deceitful sophists have racked their brain to find solid criteria of the concept of Nation, and according to their preconceived ideas, to their interests and passions, to their bias of all kinds, they have declared them answering or inapplicable to the case of the Jews. And how amusing, or sadly inconsistent many of the debaters were! There is, for instance, M. Theodore Reinach, a scholar and writer of high attainments. He composes a "History of the Jewish People," admits without the faintest attempt at contest that the Jews were a people with their own national life and fate, but declares that they suddenly ceased to be popular in 1791, when the revolutionary convention of France granted them the rights of men and citizens. By what miracle could a people disappear between one day and the other, how the Jews who before the carrying of the French law of Emancipation were a nation, lost entirely this quality after that event, he does not stop to explain. Yesterday the Jews were a nation! To-day they are a confession! Bow yourself before the fact! Do not venture to raise objections or to doubt! You must believe! It is a revelation! It is a dogma!

March, 1920