Gleanings and Echoes of the Press
A Precursor of the Balfour Declaration—Zionist Progress in Far Asia—“Halb Asien”—A Herzl Reminder
THE Manchester Guardian, a little while ago, published the hitherto secret instructions that were given by the French Government to Mr. George Picot, Commissary of the Republic in Occupied Territories in Palestine and Syria, concerning his mission to those countries. The document is dated April 2, 1917, some months before the Balfour Declaration. The following passage is contained in the instructions:
In entering Palestine you will come into contact with numerous Jewish colonies. It is desirable to grant them from the outset a large measure of protection and to mark the new situation by entrusting them with the administration of their communities and with a share in the government of the country. For you are no doubt aware that the policy pursued towards them is destined to create a profound impression, not only among their co-religionists residing in Allied and neutral countries, but even among those living in enemy countries. It would therefore be in our interest to inspire them with the greatest expectations concerning that which the Allies intend to do for them on the soil to which they are attached by a millennian past, and to which some of them desire to return in order to establish settlements.
This passage, of course, proves nothing but what every rational Jew the world over knew before its publication, viz., that the conversion of the Entente Cabinets to Zionism was not a matter of airy moods but a recognition of Jewish national sentiment throughout the Dispersion as a power capable of delivering a quid pro quo. Instead of quietly taking cognizance of this realistic foundation of Zionist prospects some London Jewish press-organs, notably the Chronicle and the World are artlessly dismayed. To the Chronicle, the revelation of the Manchester Guardian comes as a shock, naïvely avowed:
“We have hitherto regarded the Balfour Declaration as a spontaneous offer on the part of the British Government to begin the setting right of the age-long wrong to the Jew.” By way of sober second thought, the World adds:
“Practically, it may not much matter whether this was so.” By the time this goes to press, our British contemporaries, we trust, will have recovered from the shock received when the insight was forced upon them that state-pledges made to Zionism were not contracts legally flawed through a lack of good and valuable considerations.
SYRIA, PARIS, AND CERTAIN ARABIAN NIGHTS' ENTERTAINMENTS
Another feature of the days' news creating unnecessary apprehensions among ill-informed Zionists at home and abroad is the visit of Emir Feisal to Paris. During his stay, this gifted young potentate simply imitated the example of well-nigh all other representatives of the Powers—he talked Versailles in his claims for a greater Araby, with a fluency which must have been a surprise to some of his Occidental prototypes. The Zionist Review (London) with its usual good sense, takes matters coolly:
The Emir Feisal is in Paris, and apparently has not met with much good fortune there. From his own declaration, it is plain that
he had two chief objects: the first to get accepted his idea of the United Arabia, including Palestine, Syria and Mesopotamia; the second, to persuade the French to abandon the occupation of the Syrian coastal region by French troops. There is reason to believe that he was ill-advised enough to attempt to gain French support at the expense both of Great Britain and of the Zionists. Of course, intrigues of that kind were bound to be sterile, and we can only express our regret that some of the counsellors the Emir now has around him are so short-sighted and so unskilled. Since Colonel Lawrence left the Emir, the diplomacy of the Emir has been notable more for its mistakes than for its successes. The Temps, doubtless inspired from the French Foreign Office, denies absolutely that the Emir, under his agreements with Great Britain has any personal claim at all, or that there are any Arab claims upon Palestine, or upon the coastal region of Syria. It would clear the ground of mistakes of this kind if all the diplomatic documents in this case were published, and their meaning put beyond dispute. Meanwhile, the counsellors of the Emir would do well to realize that the Arab problem can be settled only by open proceedings and in harmony with all the factors concerned.
Our friend the Emir is not particularly blameworthy for falling in with ready-made Occidental conventions of statecraft as he finds them. Like other esteemed contemporaries, he claims what he knows to be impossible to get all he thinks to be possible. Arabic—like English, French, Spanish, German, Yiddish and Hebrew—is an international medium of communication, available anywhere from Morocco to Kashmir and from Cairo to Zanzibar. To base territorial claims upon the spread of the Arabic tongue is like claiming the New York East Side for the German Republic because a hybrid variant of German prevails there over every other tongue spoken. The Emir, of course, is perfectly aware of this. He is furthermore aware that the term “Syria” has been, since the days of the Romans, a purely convenient designation for an ill-defined part of the Asiatic Levant, and that no turn of the wheel of history, for centuries to come, can possibly restore an Arab Empire including the Mesopotamian dominions of the Caliphs. To doubt his insight into Near Eastern realities, is to do an injustice to his truly admirable acumen. His “claims” are simply a Versailles version of the new Arabian Nights’ Entertainments, and his friendly sentiments as regards the Zionist cause need not be doubted—they are insured by weighty British guarantees which, in their turn, are reinsured through the utter impossibility of restoring a most important link in the chain of Anglo-Levantine and Anglo-Indian traffic save by international Jewish aid and effort.
THE FUTURE OF MESOPOTAMIA
Mr. A. Burton Buckley, an inspector of irrigation in Egypt, who visited Mesopotamia in 1918 as the engineering member of a commission appointed to examine the expenditure of the British army in that country, has written a report on "Mesopotamia as a Country for Future Development" that has been published by the Egyptian Government Press at Cairo. According to the New York Sun, the report proposes the turning of Mesopotamia, through irrigation, into
