The Maccabaean
the life of all European peoples. He then takes up the history of England, France and Germany, dividing it into its various periods and showing the interdependence of their development. Special chapters are devoted to the Irish Question and the growth of the British Empire. The other countries are dealt with more briefly, except Russia, which is treated last, owing to its peculiar political situation. The author devotes an interesting chapter to the revolutionary labor movements and deals briefly with the women's movement and the important development of science. The chapter on the Near East Question, the Expansion of Europe and the International Relations, 1870-1914, explain the causes of the World War to which the thirtieth and last chapter is devoted.
The brief outline of the contents of the volume at once shows that the book is entirely modern in its historical point of view. The political history does not play the foremost part it used to up to recent times. The social, economic and cultural factors are given due prominence. Even the most notable literary achievements find place in this modern history.
On the whole, Professor Schapiro has accomplished his task admirably. He has presented the subject clearly and interestingly and has generally striven to be impartial towards men and movements. If he has not quite succeeded in his paragraph on the German Kultur, this can easily be understood at the present time. But the point is emphasized by the fact that the German literature of the last century is entirely omitted and names such as Hauptmann, Sudermann and even Nietzsche have not found a place in the chapters dealing with modern Germany. Otherwise, the writer evidently was at pains to suppress any bias of his, even against Germany. While the reviewer has found more detailed and perhaps sometimes more correct information as to minutiæ in other handbooks of a similar character, he is under the impression that Professor Schapiro succeeded better in offering a rounded out picture of the development of the last century in its various aspects. The attentive reader will find the book an excellent guide for the understanding of the present time. No one reading the few bare facts about the entrance of the Europeans into China (pp. 657-64) can fail to realize the basic injustice of modern imperialism; nor will he wonder any longer about the latest act perpetrated against China by the Western Powers.
The impression one gets is that the author is thoroughly familiar with the political and social history of England and somewhat less with that of France and Germany. These occasional slips have occurred: The Prussian king did not go to Olmütz, as we are led to infer on p. 138. The statement on p. 286 about the German army-organization is not quite correct. The Croat Jellachich was not given command of the Austrian army in Hungary but invaded that country at the head of Croatian bands. Most readers will gain the impression that the quotation from Schiller’s poem “Resignation” (p. 139), “Die Weltgeschichte ist das Weltgericht,” belongs to Hegel. The author’s translation “universal history shows a progress of universal justice” is entirely inadequate. The meaning is “history is the final judgment.” The title of Treitchke’s book is “History of Germany in the 19th Century”; it is not a general history of Germany (p. 172). It ought to have been said that Renan’s “Vie de Jesus” forms part of his “Origines du Christianisme” (p. 167). To number Clemenceau among new statesmen in 1899 (p. 256) is rather risky. The spelling “Raillies” (p. 258) would hardly be acceptable to the party described. Macterlinck ought to have caused the author to add a paragraph on Literature to Chapter XX. In the chapter on Science one misses ihe name of Ehrlich, and in the paragraph on the Liberation of Greece, Byron’s name ought not to have been omitted. But these, after all, are only minor details which can easily be remedied and in no way detract from the excellence of the book. The book would gain also if colored maps would be supplied for the plain ones (pp. 370, 409, etc.) which are not distinet enoueh.
References to Jews are quite frequent. There are several paragraphs specially devoted to them, such as Jewish Emancipation in England (pp. 79-80), the Dreyfus Affair (pp. 248-256), the Anti-Jewish Legislation in Russia (pp. 531-536) in which a few lines
deal with the beginnings of Zionism, etc. It is curious that in connection with Heine, the only representative of German belle-lettres mentioned in the book, his Jewish origin is passed over, while it is stated in references to Disraeli, Marx and Lassalle. To speak of enlistment of Jews in the army of Nicholas I (p. 533, note 2) sounds absurd, and the statement that the Zionist Congresses have been held annually is not correct.
Altogether, Professor Schapiro's European History can be very warmly recommended to any one who wishes to make himself familiar with the movements and tendencies which have produced our present conditions. The reader will find his book both interesting and instructive. The copious cross-references which the author gives all along make the consultation of the book easier and the comparative statistical data given in the footnotes well illustrate the economic growth and political development of various countries and will be found very helpful. A. M.
A. M.
Mr. Bullard’s Moscow
The Russian Pendulum. Autocracy-Democracy-Bolshevism. By ARTHUR BULLARD. The Macmillan Company. 1919; 256 pp.
Mr. Arthur Bullard, at his normal level of journalistic performance, is an ingenious and fairly well-informed young man, with a praiseworthy bent for social exploration at home and abroad and a pleasing talent of expository and descriptive presentation of his findings. In the present volume he has found, like Napoleon, his Moscow. In trying to understand revolutionary Russia and to make his readers understand it, he has attempted a task to which his head and heart are plainly not equal. There is no reason to think that he has misstated his Russian experiences\u2014some of them highly interesting but they do not help him to any true comprehension of the Russian situation, nor will they help his reader unless the reader brings more critical and comprehensive information to the perusal than the author offers. To such an exceptional reader, Mr. Bullard's personal adventures apart from his interpretation may be welcome as throwing additional light upon fairly well-known events and personalities. The general run of newspaper-fed mentalities will derive nothing from Mr. Bullard's book but additional confusion.
"The Russian Pendulum" is an unenlightening performance, chiefly for three reasons:
1. The volume, though finished in July, 1919, is limping so far behind rapidly moving Russian and world-developments as to be antiquated. On the threshold of an impending international composition with the Soviet government, its speculations concerning Allied moves are rendered nugatory by the news of the day.
2. The book is written around a thin proverbial thesis, evidently preconceived and inapplicable to Russian developments —namely that anti-absolutist upheavals on a great scale move in a pendulum-swing from autocracy to anarchy and back. Mr. Bullard posits the Kerensky régime—that phantom of a few anarchic Russian weeks—as a sort of democratic Paradise Lost, midway between autocracy and anarchy. His pages leave a strong impression that, starting on his recent “mission,” Mr. Bullard brought his Kerensky theory ready-made with him to Russia. In the light of recent developments in Hungary, Rumania, Poland, Ukrainia, Austria, his insistence that Russia must be “made safe for democracy,” sounds like the echo of a ghastly joke coming from an immense remoteness of historical backgrounds. A strange and uncanny sense of vast distances covered in a few months overcomes the reader of such concluding pronouncements of Mr. Bullard’s as the following:
“There is considerable noisy shouting in favor of a ‘hands-ofRussia’ policy. But the general sentiment in America, as near 3 I can gauge it, is that we should ‘stand by’... It may, I think, be safely assumed that the tendency of the allied nations, while trying to safeguard the interests of the formerly subjugated nations, will be to preserve the frontiers of Russia as they existed in 1914” To this finale our readers will please mentally supply as many exclamstion-marks and italicized sic’s as they find necessary to express their sense of superiority over such abysmal infatuation. AL.
