The Maccabaean
there was such wealth of opportunity on every hand, that we . . . traveled through France, Switzerland, Italy, Spain, Belgium and Holland. At last we sailed homeward, leaving Southampton May 10, 1919. . . Up to the time we waved good-by at the Southampton docks, I had had no remote intention of writing a book about European affairs. . . From title to finis, every line was dictated in the five days between Southampton and Halifax. And so it should be taken for what it is—a quick review following an extremely interesting experience in observing a state of affairs so novel that the whole world's history has nothing comparable to offer. . . America must understand how her own fortune—her own future—are bound up with the fate of European civilization, and that European civilization is confronted with extreme dangers. Without America's help, the catastrophe cannot be averted, I believe—but by America's help I do not mean America's charity." There is no topic of present-day discussion of such far-reaching import as this very help, its nature, extent and organization. Without a careful perusal of Mr. Vanderlip's book an intelligent discussion of this overshadowing topic—and of the future of both Europe and America—is well-night impossible for the general run of newspaper-informed (and misinformed) Americans.
Waldo Frank's America
Our America, by WALDO FRANK. Boni & Liveright, New York.
This book would not have been written—as the author is frank enough to confess—had not a person by the name of Van Wyck Brooks presented a theory concerning the nature of American life as dictated by the necessities of pioneering. That theory is to be found in Mr. Brooks' Letters and Leadership and may be summed up in the following manner:
America, through the necessities which an undeveloped land laid upon its inhabitants, has permitted itself to be mastered by its crassly acquisitive impulses and has smothered its creative impulses to the end that literature and art and philosophy and music, instead of being regarded as aspects of reality (to be enjoyed, rather than appreciated) are regarded merely as a means of escape from that ugly industrialism which we have come to accept as the only kind of reality worth bothering about. And so, because the acquisitive impulses have had their own spiritually destructive way with us, literature and art and music and philosophy have always been subordinated to the only generally accepted reality and have been colored and shaped by the requirements of, and in conformity to, that generally accepted reality. Our industrial life has made for a reversion of values so that we hardly know, if we ever did, what is worth while and what is not.
This is the theory Mr. Frank has accepted. He has, however, carried it slightly further, with the aid of psychoanalysis, has called upon it for explanation of a diversity of phenomena, which, to the intellectually undirected mass of us, are not bound together and has fused it with the Randolph Bourne theory concerning the function of pragmatism as a philosophical justification for materialism and compromise.
Mr. Frank has attempted to tell us of "Our America" in terms of the Van Wyck Brooks and Randolph Bourne theories. Not as a sociologist or historical grubber or bookworm, but as an inhabitant of the Empyrean, from which he takes what appears to him as a thoroughly integrated view of a panorama that is to us unorganized, baffling, contradictory.
He subordinates the facts to his theory, that the theory may be justified, not that the facts may be presented. That is perhaps necessary in a volume so closely integrated as a volume of this kind ought to be, but it works to the exclusion of much vital material. There are, in consequence, deficiencies, limitations, over-ratings, under-ratings. It is an intensely personal book. It is a book picturing Waldo Frank's America rather than the America of even an exclusive group. But if we accept it on that understanding, it is a masterpiece, a triumph. Here, he seems to say, you will find my preferences, my abominations; the things that I
accept, the things that I reject. America has resolved about him; one could understand what his conclusions would be from the distinct bias of his mind. But although, as I have said, this book synthesizes the Van Wyck Brooks and Randolph Bourne theories concerning American life, it is not the expression of a theory. It is a prose epic, the matter of which is informed by those theories and which would have not been without its beauty even had he written from the conventional point of view, although it would have lacked the particular beauty of revolt. For he writes with literary afflatus which, in its cruder form, possesses schoolboys with pronounced literary aspirations. To the hypercritical and unsympathetic it would appear that Mr. Frank has suffered from the exquisite pain of a literary orgasm and from it produced "Our America" If quotations ever damned a book, quotations from "Our America" would easily damn it, but these quotations, it should be colorful suggestion. He writes, for instance: "The voluptuous exactness of simple logic" and expects the lay reader to follow out the processes involved in the construction of this startling simile. His absurd desire to idealize the rejected leads him to say of Debs, Haywood and Emma Goldman that they are "religious, nostalgic for prisons." His love for simile is simply overpowering. He has "the brittle brilliance of Fifth Avenue"; "the houses spew out their human provender"; "a lofty, arrogant, lustful city, beaten through an iron rhythm"; "the colors of his (Emerson's) words brush like the dust on a moth's wing." He also writes with the Philistines will doubt him, when he states: "Art with a message is a profanation."
He has evolved an interesting theory concerning the Jew in America, a theory which sounds like a theory in the exactness with which all the facts he quotes jibe with it. Nowhere is his love for the unifying theory more apparent than in his chapter on “The Chosen People”; apparent because, in the effort to maintain the theoretical unity of the book, he is forced into the defense of a false position, namely, that the pioneering Jews in their will-to-power and in the justification for that will-to-power that their pragmatic theology gave ihem were kin to the Puritans.. When he writes, “In their intense and isolated will, the Puritan and Jew were kin,” he expresses his desire not to break, even temporarily, with the theory which he has chosen to explain America. He continues: “Like the Jew, the Puritan was obsessed with the dream of power, elected a career of separatism from the world to attain it, took to himself a personal and exacting God to justify it, traversed the seas in order to effect it. And as with the’ Puritan, so with the Jew, once free in a vast country, the urge of power swiftiy shook ofl its religious and pietistic way and drove untrammeled to material aggression.” There is perfect literary symmetry in the passage just quoted, but is it true? For a man so fond of fine writing as Mr. Frank is, there is a constant temptation to produce a fine effect. Whether the facts are adhered to is a matter which, it seems, only pedants and statisticians are interested in. H. S.
A Handbook of Modern History
Modern and Contemporary European History. By J. SALWYN SCHAPIRO, Ph.D., Associate Professor of History in the College of the City of New York. Under the editorship of JAMES T. SHOTWELL, Ph.D., Professor of History in Columbia University. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin Company. Fifth Impression. XIV —766—XLVIII pp., 8vo.
In these times when America has been drawn into the maelstrom af European politics, the history of the Western Continent has become of much more interest to us than ever before. In order to understand properly the foreign news of the daily papers, a certain acquaintance with the past of these countries is indispensable. The general information required for an adequate understanding of our own times is very well summarized in Professor Schapiro’s book, which describes the history of the last century down to the Armistice endinge the Great War.