The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXIII, No. 2 · February 1920
61printed page
scan 19 of 36

The Maccabaean

And they criticise the purchase of the implements and furnishings. They allow for a representative of the Zion Commonwealth in the administration but would limit its scope, especially with regard to the selection of the original hundred pupil-laborers and the subsequent settlers. These differences do not appear irreducible. But, unfortunately, the protracted negotiations have proceeded to a point which generate and accentuate misunderstanding. Neither side is now in a humor to yield. The representatives of the "Ahduth Avodah" who have, curiously enough, been acting for the men, have declared that the negotiations have been broken off.

Thus, instead of a hundred Legionaires being actually employed in Balfouria (as reported in THE MAccABABAN for September) the men are still in khaki, marking time. Assuming even that the differences will be smoothed over and work in Balfouria should eventually commence, it shoula be remembered that only one hundred will be provided employment. There are, roughly, another hundred and fifty who have waived their claim to repatriation in order to be demobilized in Palestine. This faithful remnant which could not be induced to leave the country, and are serving while most of their comrades are in America, in the happy state of the “demobbed,” must have work at once. The unctuous resolution adopted at the Chicago Convention directing the American Organization and the International Zionist Organization to give the opportunity to settle in Palestine to those who wish it is, therefore, not without its touch of irony. The chairman of the Resolutions Committee on Palestine had every opportunity of knowing that the problem of settling those who desire to be settled in Palestine was beyond the help of well-intentioned resolutions. The provisions referred to should have been made one year ago, at the latest. Then the numbers who embraced repatriation would undoubtedly have been ever so much smaller, while the number remaining: in Palestine ever so much greater. One wonders what has become of the promising Pittsburgh resolution. And two hundred and fifty American Legionaires awaiting their discharge in Palestine are wondering what has become of the other grand schemes by which their faith in their American comrades had been sustained to the last. They are not disheartened— these hardy youths who could not be induced to leave Palestine. Oh, no! They are simply wonderine.

* * *

The notoriously excessive cost of living is causing great concern. There is little consolation in the knowledge that the high prices, like the political conditions, are transitory. For one thing they have been transitory too long. Wages are higher than ever but, as in Europe and America, commodities are still out of reach. The usual thing has happened: Increased wages only meant increased cost of living. Those who have studied the problem declare that the prices of some commodities are from a hundred to two hundred per cent. above the rates obtainable in Europe or America. And I have been told by land laborers that before, and even during the war they could buy more with their seven piastres (thirty-five cents) a day than now with thirty piastres (one dollar and fifty cents).

At last a partial effort is being made to combat the abnormal prices. The administration of Tel Aviv has undertaken to regulate the prices of food sold in the markets. The Vaad threatens to cancel the licenses of storekeepers who

February, 1920

will not keep within the limits of the fixed prices. A large quantity of flour has been brought from Egypt to Jerusalem to be sold by a local committee at a reasonable rate. In Jaffa it is proposed to start a sort of co-operative society by "organizing the consumers to control the . . . distribution of things needed to satisfy their wants." Mr. Hoofien, of the Anglo-Palestine Company, has published a pamphlet on the subject. In this pamphlet he follows out some of the suggestions contained in Mr. Warbasse's recent article in THE MACCABAEAN. But Mr. Hoofien proposes to limit the membership of this society, for the present, to the employees of the national administrative offices —the Bank, Zionist Commission, Palestine office, etc. This limitation is too serious to be disregarded. It is difficult to appreciate why the "pekiddim" and residents of Tel Aviv, whose earnings are, on the whole, greater should benefit from such a movement first. The residents of "Neoe Zedek" and "Neoe Sholom" in Jaffa and "Meah Shearim" in Jerusalem and the long-suffering Yemenites ought, certainly, to have articles of food made accessible. Surely the distress in those quarters is greater than in Tel Aviv. It is too much and, perhaps only premature, to hope that the civil employees and teachers and "pekiddim" in general will adopt Dr. Bograchov's plan to have their salaries brought down to the laborer's level. But if there is no leveling in the wage-scale there should be equality before the brutal, common enemy—extortionate prices.

* * *

I am bound to tell American Zionists that the alleged reports of the “declaration of independence” of the American Zionist Medical Unit has made a very unfavorable impression. It appears, from reliable sources, that the present medical director of the Unit, resenting some suggestions from the administration of the Zionist Commission cabled the American Organization requesting to be declared free of the discipline of the Zionist Commission. To this unusual request the American Organization is said to have cabled an affirmative reply. As this incident is supposed to have followed closely after the appearance of a particularly irritating artice by Dr. Rubinow, the Hadassah Director, on the Hebrew language in the new daily, “Doar Hayom,” fuel was added to the fire. Old-time grievances against Hadassah methods which seemed for a time to have given way, after better understanding of those methods, are more energetically than ever beine emphasized.

The "Poal Hazair" of November 3, comments in part: "No one wishes to question the value of the Medical Unit or the practical utility of its work. But we have one, and not two, Zionist Organizations. And to the rule of two powers in Palestine we shall never consent, because it would spell the beginning of bankruptcy in all our work. The American Zionist Organization has earned, without doubt, our gratitude for the comprehensive aid it has extended in these days of want. It has discharged, and is still discharging, its duty faithfully—but it must be aware that special privileges are not bought with money . . ."

The author is not justified in charging the American Organization with deliberate intent to buy special privileges. One may doubt to what extent the general allegation is true. But the spirit in which the supposed independence of "Hadassah" has been received in liberal quarters may well serve as a guide in the future Palestinian dealings of the American Zionist.

Sixty-One