The Maccabaean
sentative, since this was not a charitable fund (accountable to the "general public," which usually means to no one in particular), but a trust fund, accumulated by the savings of individual members, many of whom hoped to become personal settlers in Palestine. This was not a case of capital versus labor, but rather analogous to the case of the relationship between policyholders in a mutual life insurance company and the agents and other "laborers" in the Company necessary in the normal transaction of its business.
It is not surprising, however, that after the president of the American Zion Commonwealth left Palestine, some of the Legionaires should have misunderstood the project, since there has been little time, as yet, for education and propaganda. The American Zion Commonwealth was gravely told, by some misguided critics, that it had no right to name the colony “Balfouria,” without the consent and approval of the Legionaires; that the Legionaires alone should select their own overseers and agricultural expert; that the land should be given to the Legionaires, and that the American . Zion Commonwealth should, in addition, generously furnish the entire finances necessary for the enterprise. In short, the American Zion Commonwealth was advised by some critics to supply the money, while it would be rigidly excluded from controlling the expenditures and from guiding the enterprise. Of course, our capable and honest representative, Miss Nellie Straus, knew enough about business to understand that such a plan would mean, simply, that the American Zion Commonwealth’ would be required to meet the periodic deficits. She promptly and properly rejected these overtures, and Balfouria is now operating on a business basis, safeguarding the rights of our members and investors, while scrupulously fair to the Jewish laborers —our comrades in the co-operative enterprise of upbuilding a Jewish Palestine.
The name "Balfouria" was suggested by a Jewess in Galilee, and this suggestion was cabled by the president of the American Zion Commonwealth to Dr. Chaim Weizmann (then in London), who approved the idea and secured the full endorsement of the Hon. Arthur James Balfour before the name "Balfouria" was officially announced. The American Zion Commonwealth takes pride in coupling the name of the man responsible for the "Balfour Declaration" with the first colonizing efforts since the Great War, and subsequent settlers in Balfouria should graciously accept that name even as newcomers who consent to live as inhabitants of London, New York or Jerusalem.
The American Zion Commonwealth intends to carry out its program of profit-sharing, but, obviously, you can only talk of profit-sharing after there is a surplus. At the present time, our first duty is to create that surplus and not to dispute about the division of dividends, which are, as yet, non-existent. The American Zion Commonwealth stands pledged to carry out its plan of a co-operative industrial army, and the experiences of the next two years will teach us how to build up such an army on a proper economic
basis. Palestine is a failure so long as it cannot assure reasonable return on invested capital, and Palestine will be a success only after the profits on invested capital become large enough to demand and enforce a just system of profit-sharing and co-operation. It is the purpose of the American Zion Commonwealth to strive for the just rewards of labor, not through any magic formula of any single economic theory, but rather as an outgrowth of the experiences gained in the "struggle for existence" in Palestine itself.
No one can tell, with any certainty, the kind of a Jewish commonwealth that will be established in Palestine. But we must have some rough plan and a fairly definite ultimate aim, even as an architect who builds a house must have a plan suitable to the occupant. We who are building the House of Israel have drawn up a plan embodied in the Pittsburgh Program —a plan that would encourage co-operative action and would provide that the profits due to the growth of the community shall benefit equally all the inhabitants of Palestine. But the Pittsburgh Program must not be interpreted as a monopoly plan for the upbuilding of Palestine—as "the be-all and the end-all"—but rather as a "path of progress." We believe that in the struggle for the upbuilding of Palestine the Pittsburgh Program, because it represents the idealism of the Jewish people, will win out; but unless such a program should be triumphant in the competitive struggle with individual initiative, it is of no real value. The co-operative movement in Great Britain has succeeded despite—or perhaps because—of a trade war with private enterprise extending over two generations. Such a competition has compelled the co-operative stores to be constantly on the alert; to be more efficient than private enterprise. On the other hand, the indirect results of co-operation have been even more important than the direct benefits. By instituting a saving system for consumers, it has compelled private interests to keep their profits within fair and legitimate limits.
The American Zion Commonwealth should fulfill the function of a vast co-operative enterprise for Palestine, not to the exclusion of individual initiative, but rather in a constant activity, whereby each will supplement the other. If in any particular business activity the American Zion Commonwealth should crowd out private enterprise, then this would be ample proof that private enterprise, in that line, is less efficient and ought to stay out. But in the meanwhile let us employ all methods in the difficult task of upbuilding the Land of Israel. Let us have the same goal, even though some of us may travel by different routes.
In America the American Zion Commonwealth will continue its activity as a co-operative institution for the accumulation of individual savings into a huge Land Fund; while in Palestine, through the development of a co-operative industrial army on the lands of the Zion Commonwealth and the creation of a complementary Co-operative Kehillah of Consumers, who will share in the profits, we shall gradually approach the goal of industrial democracy.